When comparing Pillivuyt Lasagne Baker vs Circulon Symmetry Casserole, the Slant community recommends Pillivuyt Lasagne Baker for most people. In the question“What are the best casserole dishes around or under $100?” Pillivuyt Lasagne Baker is ranked 1st while Circulon Symmetry Casserole is ranked 2nd. The most important reason people chose Pillivuyt Lasagne Baker is:
In the process of making this casserole dish, the porcelain is heated up to 2500 ºF. This makes it highly resistant to thermal shock. You can safely put the casserole in the -22 ºF freezer, later transfer it straight into the hot oven (up to 662 ºF), and after the food is done, use the baker on the table as a serving dish.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Can go from the freezer straight to the oven and then be served on the table
In the process of making this casserole dish, the porcelain is heated up to 2500 ºF. This makes it highly resistant to thermal shock. You can safely put the casserole in the -22 ºF freezer, later transfer it straight into the hot oven (up to 662 ºF), and after the food is done, use the baker on the table as a serving dish.
Pro Extremely durable and chip-resistant
This casserole dish is very durable: thick high-fired porcelain makes it much more resistant to scratches and chips than stoneware, enameled cast iron, or non-stick coated dishes.
Pro Rectangular shape convenient for even portioning
The rectangular shape of this lasagne baker lends itself to easy and even food portioning, which can be more tricky in oblong or round casserole dishes.
Pro Easy to clean and dishwasher safe
The porcelain glazed surface of this lasagna baker is non-porous and slick, so food does not stick to it. Any burnt food residue easily comes off with a bit of soaking in warm water. The dish can also be safely put in the dishwasher.
Pro Light and easy to handle
The Circulon Symmetry Casserole dish is made from anodized aluminum and weighs only 5.7 lbs. It has two large and comfortable silicone handles on the sides and one on the lid. This makes the pot easily maneuverable even for people with weaker wrists. It also reduces the chances of getting burned or the dish slipping from the hands of the cook.
Pro Excellent for one-pot stovetop to oven recipes
This Circulon casserole dish (unlike stoneware/porcelain dishes) is safe to use on any kind of stovetop as well as in the oven. Both the pot and the glass lid can handle temperatures of up to 400 °F.
Pro Durable non-stick cooking surface
This casserole dish is coated with 3 layers of hard PFOA-free non-stick material. Care instructions even specify that metal utensils can be used in this dish (though it is better to use wooden/plastic/silicone, as with all non-stick cookware). Raised concentric circles on the cooking surface help reduce surface abrasion and loss of non-stick properties.
Cons
Con Can't be used on the stovetops
This casserole dish should not be used on the stovetops. The retailers state that it is possible with a heat diffuser, but there is a high risk for the vessel to shatter when the heat only comes from the bottom. This baker is best used only in the oven, microwave, grill or under the broiler.
Con Does not have a lid
This Pillivuyt casserole dish does not have an accompanying lid. It can be covered with aluminum foil or third-party silicone cover.
Con Not compatible with microwave, broiler, or grill
Due to the materials it's made of (aluminum body, non-stick coating, and silicone handles), this casserole dish is not suitable for heat sources other than the stovetop and the oven. Since the highest temperature it can handle is 400 °F, this pot cannot be used on a grill or under a broiler. It is also not microwave-compatible because of the aluminum body of the dish.
Con The food in the middle and upper layers will take more time to warm up
This casserole dish has a tapered bottom (9.5-inch diameter in the middle, 8-inch diameter on the bottom) and is quite tall (6.4 inches). The reduced contact area with the burner means that it takes more time to heat the contents of the dish all the way through.
Alternative Products
