When comparing Medela Breastmilk Bottle vs Mixie Formula-Mixing Baby Bottle, the Slant community recommends Mixie Formula-Mixing Baby Bottle for most people. In the question“What are the best baby bottles?” Mixie Formula-Mixing Baby Bottle is ranked 1st while Medela Breastmilk Bottle is ranked 3rd. The most important reason people chose Mixie Formula-Mixing Baby Bottle is:
This bottle allows you to prepare the formula in advance. It reduces the risk of exposing the milk to unsanitary conditions when you open the formula can and water container just anywhere.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Useful for moms who pump breastmilk
The rim of Medela bottles fit many types of pumps for collecting breastmilk. You can pump breastmilk into these bottles, use them for storage in the freezer and heat them in the warmer when it's time to feed your baby. This is more convenient than pouring milk from separate storage bottles to feeding bottles.
Pro Great for long-term storage of breastmilk
They are designed to withstand the extreme temperatures of freezers and bottle warmers. You can directly store your pumped breastmilk in these bottles and place them in the freezer for a long period of time. This eliminates the need of purchasing a different set of storage bottles.
Pro Prevents contamination
This bottle allows you to prepare the formula in advance. It reduces the risk of exposing the milk to unsanitary conditions when you open the formula can and water container just anywhere.
Pro Lessens the things you need to bring along
The Mixie has a built-in compartment at the bottom. It keeps the formula separate from the water until you pop the button on the bottle to mix them. This design minimizes the need to pack a formula container, water, and bottles separately. It also eliminates the need to use a cooler to pack pre-mixed formula.
Cons
Con This bottle's nipple is not similar to the breast
When switching between breastfeeding and bottle feeding, you'll likely succeed with bottle nipples that are more like natural breasts. However, the Medela nipples are small, unlike a mother's nipples which are usually elongated. Also. the milk flow from a Medela nipple is fast and does not mimic the natural slow flow of a mother's milk.
Con Requires thorough cleaning
The Mixie has more pieces than the standard baby bottle and it takes more time to clean. Although a dishwasher does a fine job of quickly cleaning it, those who choose to hand wash the bottle have to spend extra time and effort brushing the small parts to make sure no left-over milk is stuck in the nooks and crannies.