When comparing Yamaha HS8 vs Mackie HR824mk2, the Slant community recommends Yamaha HS8 for most people. In the question“What are the best high-end studio monitors? ” Yamaha HS8 is ranked 1st while Mackie HR824mk2 is ranked 4th. The most important reason people chose Yamaha HS8 is:
These speakers are great for those who want to get accurate audio without spending thousands of dollars. The HS8 produce neutral and accurate sound that is great for mixing. The highs are clean and airy, but do not get harsh. The mids sound natural and full, so vocals and guitars can clearly be heard. The bass is tight and has a great punch yet never gets out of control.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Neutral and balanced sound
These speakers are great for those who want to get accurate audio without spending thousands of dollars. The HS8 produce neutral and accurate sound that is great for mixing. The highs are clean and airy, but do not get harsh. The mids sound natural and full, so vocals and guitars can clearly be heard. The bass is tight and has a great punch yet never gets out of control.
Pro You can adjust the sound to fit your room
It’ll be easy for you to get the most accurate audio output from these speakers. The HS8’s Room control switches allow you to cut down volume levels to minimize sound reflections if your room is not acoustically treated.
Pro Treble levels can be tweaked
You can easily tweak the treble levels to your liking. At the back of each HS8 speaker is a High Trim switch which gives you the option to increase or decrease treble levels by 2dB.
Pro They can produce high volume levels
These speakers can easily fill a medium to large-sized studio with sound. The 8-inch woofers and 1-inch tweeter are able to pump out high levels of volume without distorting, so you aren’t likely to find the sound lacking.
Pro Multiple wired input options available
These speakers will work with most pro-level mixers and audio interfaces. The input options are balanced XLR and TRS which should cover a wide range of studio devices.
Pro Solid build quality
The HS8 speakers give the impression that they will last you many years of use. The cabinets are made out of thick wood and are quite heavy.
Pro Accurate sound, room controls and good build quality at a great price
The HS8 studio monitors are able to deliver a flat sound that is good enough for mixing along with room adjustments and solid build quality, but at a price that is significantly less than other high end options.
Pro Loud, full and accurate sound
These monitors are great if you have a large studio and you want to fill it with sound. The HR824mk2 speakers are able to pump out a lot of volume without losing any clarity.
The sound is also very accurate. The highs are very clean and airy, revealing every detail of the music. The mids are warm full and very natural while the bass has great depth and punch, but does not get overpowering.
Pro Vertical connectors
These speakers can easily be mounted flush against the wall if that’s what your setup requires. The cables do not stick out from the back of the speakers horizontally. Instead, the cable connectors are vertical, so there will be no cable obstructions between the wall and the speaker.
Pro You’ll be able to get the optimal sound for your room
It’ll be easier for you to get the most accurate audio performance from these speakers regardless of your room setup. There is an Acoustic Space switch at the back of the speakers which correspond to how you position the speakers. Each setting has an illustration at the back of the speaker, minimizing the guesswork as to which one is best for you.
Pro Audio output can be adjusted
You can tweak the sound according to your preferences. You get switches for Low and High Frequency trims so you can reduce the bass if you find it too boomy or increase/decrease the highs to your liking.
Cons
Con Only High Trim controls are available
You won’t be able to customize the sound as extensively as the older model, the HS80m. Those speakers had Mid and Bass trim options, which allowed more sound tweaking.
Con Bass might not be enough
If you are a bass head, then the tight and controlled bass output may not be powerful enough for you. A subwoofer like the Yamaha HS8S would be a good companion to the HS8s if you want deep and more powerful low-end.
Con Cabinet is large and heavy
You might have difficulty positioning these speakers if your studio space is limited. The speaker cabinet is large and heavy so setting these up optimally can be a challenge.
Con Bass is slightly boosted
Some consider the bass to be a bit too powerful for their tastes. You can reduce this by using the Low Frequency Cut switch.