When comparing Kidde Pro 210 Fire Extinguisher vs First Alert AF400 Tundra Fire Extinguishing Aerosol Spray, the Slant community recommends Kidde Pro 210 Fire Extinguisher for most people. In the question“What are the best fire extinguishers under $50?” Kidde Pro 210 Fire Extinguisher is ranked 1st while First Alert AF400 Tundra Fire Extinguishing Aerosol Spray is ranked 2nd. The most important reason people chose Kidde Pro 210 Fire Extinguisher is:
The Kidde Pro is an ABC-rated, chemical fire extinguisher, meaning it can handle all types of blazes: combustibles/conventional, flammable liquids, and electrical. While it's size and weight make it a perfect household unit, it is equally suitable for industrial use such as in offices, schools, hotels, and other businesses.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro ABC-rated fire extinguisher (it can fight all types of fires)
The Kidde Pro is an ABC-rated, chemical fire extinguisher, meaning it can handle all types of blazes: combustibles/conventional, flammable liquids, and electrical. While it's size and weight make it a perfect household unit, it is equally suitable for industrial use such as in offices, schools, hotels, and other businesses.
Pro Durable and sturdy unit
This fire extinguisher comprises a powder-coated cylinder, a brass valve (that’s ready for use as soon as it's needed), and a chrome-plated trigger. The unit is therefore protected against corrosion and feels durable and sturdy to use.
Pro Extinguisher can be easily mounted to or hung on a wall
This extinguisher features a plastic hanger and a wall mount. The plastic hanger allows you to hang up the cylinder where you can access it quickly, while the wall mount makes it easy to mount to a wall wherever it may be needed. In fact, the unit is U.S. Coast Guard approved when used with the optional mounting bracket.
Pro Lightweight aluminum cylinder
The Kidde Pro only weighs 7 lbs, making it lighter than a large bag of sugar. Units of this size make particularly good laundry room and kitchen extinguishers.
Pro Affordable
Of the larger fire extinguishers on the market, the Kidde Pro is one of the cheapest at $46.94.
Pro Impressive discharge range
The Kidde Pro can discharge up to 15 feet in a time of 13 to 15 seconds.
Pro Rechargeable
The Kidde Pro can be refilled for cheap after it has been used.
Pro Features a pressure gauge
The Kidde comes with a high quality pressure gauge that allows for immediate pressure status checks.
Pro Excellent discharge time and area
The discharge time of the Tundra is 32 seconds, which is two-four times longer than that of regular extinguishers, making it ideal for quickly fighting common household fires. It also comprises a wide-spray nozzle that can spray a greater surface area and thus give you greater control in extinguishing a fire. It's recommended to use the product about 3 to 4 feet away from the fire.
Pro Fights all types of small fires
This fire extinguishing spray can be used to put out small A, B, and C class fires. Such fires could involve paper, fabric, wood, cooking oils, electrical appliances, and equipment.
Pro Minimizes damage to your property
The Tundra spray contains a biodegradable formula that won't damage appliances, equipment, or countertop surfaces following its use. And if you do have to use the product, you simply need to wipe it away with a damp cloth, making post-blaze clean-up much less of a fuss.
Pro Highly portable
This aerosol spray is so light and compact that it can be transported easily from one place to another. As such, it's ideal for the kitchen, garage, boat, RV, and even for travel.
Pro Lightweight and easy to use
Tundra comes in a light aerosol can that is easy to hold, carry, and use. It can be stored in cabinets and drawers, next to the fireplace, underneath the sink, or anywhere else you think you might need it. What's more, it's much less intimidating to utilize than a heavy, traditional fire extinguisher, particularly for those who may lack physical strength.
Pro Affordable
A two-pack of Tundra is only $25.
Cons
Con Contains the corrosive mono-ammonium phosphate
Like most ABC fire extinguishers, the Kidde Pro is filled with mono-ammonium phosphate, a dry chemical agent that is corrosive. As such, users should be aware that using this type of extinguisher will create a mess and the only way to remove it from surfaces is by vigorously scrubbing it.
Con Kidde has been prone to recalls in the recent past
In the past number of years, Kidde has had to recall a significant number of fire extinguishers due to faults reported by users.
Con Lacks pressure gauge
There is no pressure gauge on the Tundra can, meaning you can't check its pressure status.
Con Non-rechargeable
Once the Tundra fire extinguisher has been used up or expired, you’ll need to buy a new one.
Con Use of aerosol extinguishers discouraged by experts
Generally-speaking, experts warn against the use of aerosol extinguishers, advising that they only be used as a supplement to regular fire extinguishers and not as a replacement.