Add to Chrome
Add to Edge
Add to Firefox
Add to Opera
Add to Brave
Add to SafariWhen comparing SentrySafe 1170BLK vs First Alert 2017F Water and Fire Protector Chest, the Slant community recommends SentrySafe 1170BLK for most people. In the question“What are the best fireproof document safes under $50?” SentrySafe 1170BLK is ranked 1st while First Alert 2017F Water and Fire Protector Chest is ranked 2nd. The most important reason people chose SentrySafe 1170BLK is:
The main purpose of the SentrySafe is to store important documents and files such as birth and marriage certificates, passports, tax papers, life insurance papers, social security data, etc. These items need to be stored in a safe place that, on the one hand, keeps them organized and orderly, and on the other, protects them from harmful elements such as fire and water. This safe is also particularly well-suited to the job due to its size, which is big enough to house full-sized document folders without having to fold them. At the same time, however, the SentrySafe is small enough to hide away under a bed or in a small closet, for example.
Specs
Question Ranking
Pros
Pro Keeps important documents safe and organized at the same time
The main purpose of the SentrySafe is to store important documents and files such as birth and marriage certificates, passports, tax papers, life insurance papers, social security data, etc. These items need to be stored in a safe place that, on the one hand, keeps them organized and orderly, and on the other, protects them from harmful elements such as fire and water. This safe is also particularly well-suited to the job due to its size, which is big enough to house full-sized document folders without having to fold them. At the same time, however, the SentrySafe is small enough to hide away under a bed or in a small closet, for example.
Pro Fire and water proof
The SentrySafe is UL Classified Fire Endurance certified, meaning it can successfully protect documents and any other valuables in 1550°F heat for a period of up to 30 minutes (most residential fires last less than 30 minutes). It's designed in such a way that if it's caught up in a fire, the heat causes its lid to weld shut so that its contents are completely protected. As such, not only are its contents protected from fire but also from any water that may used by the firemen to put it out.
Pro Simple but safe locking system
The SentrySafe features a privacy key lock comprising a basic locking mechanism that can be opened using a key. Potential buyers should also note that in order to make locking and unlocking easier, they should get into the habit of pushing down on the safe lid when turning the key.
Pro Convenient to access
This safe comprises a top opening lid that makes for easier, more convenient access to your documents and/or other valuable items.
Pro Looks good
The SentrySafe has a modern, stylish design that won't make it look like a complete eyesore in a room.
Pro Capable of floating
While the waterproof seal on the First Alert ensures that the safe's contents remain dry during a flood, it likewise enables the safe to float, making it easy to locate in the aftermath.
Pro Fire and water proof
The First Alert keeps its contents safe and dry from both fire and water. It's UL classified to survive external temperatures of 1550°F for a period of up to 30 minutes, all the while protecting the valuables it contains. It's also independently verified to protect digital media, including memory sticks, CD's, DVD's, and external hard drives. What's more, its waterproof seal keeps contents dry, even when completely submerged in water.
Pro Trustworthy brand
"First Alert" is one of the most recognized and trusted American brands that specializes in home safety and security products.
Pro Durable construction
Constructed from PDA plastic and containing a concrete fill, the First Alert is a heavy-duty safe that's built to withstand harsh elements.
Pro Ideal for storing documents and small items
The First Alert is the perfect size for storing letter-sized documents (lying flat) as well as other small valuable items.
Pro Can be carried easily and safely
The First Alert features a handle that makes it convenient to carry and transport if needs be. It's also secured by a clamping-style latch with a key lock.
Cons
Con Not entirely thief-proof
The SentrySafe offers basic security but it wasn't designed for anti-theft purposes. To that end, it won't prevent entry from a determined thief who is equipped with the right burgling tools. This is not a flaw as such, but rather something that potential buyers should bear in mind.
Con Doesn’t come with a document hanger
If you wish to optimize the organization of your documents in this safe, you can use a folder hanger which will separate and order files accordingly. Unfortunately, the safe doesn't come with a hanger, meaning this would have to be bought separately.
Con Cumbersome to carry
The SentrySafe doesn’t have a handle or finger ledges on its sides that would make carrying it easier.
Con May require airing from time to time
Some users have reported their documents feeling humid-like following an extended period of being sealed in the safe. As such, the First Alert may need to be aired once in a while so to avoid a build-up of moisture and/or mold.
