When comparing Everybody Edits vs Town of Salem, the Slant community recommends Town of Salem for most people. In the question“What are the best browser-based multiplayer games?” Town of Salem is ranked 2nd while Everybody Edits is ranked 13th. The most important reason people chose Town of Salem is:
The main aspect of the game is that you never know if anyone is lying to you at any particular time. This also goes for the player as well, as you can lie to anyone anytime. Which makes for quite the guessing game that asks of the player to use their deduction skills. When doing this with large groups and especially groups of friends this can make for a fun time trying to figure out who is doing what in the game.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Design your own levels live
As the name of the game implies you are given the possibility of editing. You can start with something already made and make it your own or build something from scratch. And you can do it all in real time, while you and others are running around in the game.
Pro Delightfully cruel
Levels can be changed on the fly in the most frustrating ways possible (disappearing floors, changed goals, altered layouts, etc) while you alongside other people are trying to reach the end.
Pro Very challenging
They frustrate you, but if you can handle it, you are rewarded.
Pro In-game chat
Pro Fun bluffing based gameplay
The main aspect of the game is that you never know if anyone is lying to you at any particular time. This also goes for the player as well, as you can lie to anyone anytime. Which makes for quite the guessing game that asks of the player to use their deduction skills. When doing this with large groups and especially groups of friends this can make for a fun time trying to figure out who is doing what in the game.
Pro The game keeps you playing, it's actually original
You can't find a game where you are this involved with other players anywhere else on the internet.
Pro Dedicated player base
Tons of people are playing Town of Salem and its different game modes, so you won't have a problem finding people to play with.
Pro Diverse gameplay
There are so many different game modes and roles to add.
Cons
Con Very few players
Everybody Edits is dying.
Con Requires flash
Needs Flash in your browser.
Con A lot of renegades
There are players that like going on their own and killing innocent people without any clue or strategy.
Con Gamethrowing
Sometimes, players act against their goals to win. For example, a member of the Mafia may end up purposefully revealing the whole Mafia. At that point the game is practically over. Luckily, you can report people who are gamethrowing within the game itself.
Con Uses Adobe Flash
Most browsers are starting to deprecate Flash as a plugin, (unless you have a browser like Google Chrome, which uses its own fork of Flash) you won't be able to play this game without having to purchase it on Steam.
Con High learning curve
It may be best to read up on this game and familiarize oneself to the rules and mechanics as well as common abbreviations. One particular aspect to learn about would be the 29 different roles found in the game, as you may be any one of them at the beginning of a game.