When comparing Rug Doctor Deep Carpet Cleaner vs Hoover Power Scrub Deluxe FH50150, the Slant community recommends Hoover Power Scrub Deluxe FH50150 for most people. In the question“What are the best carpet cleaners for deep cleaning under or around $200?” Hoover Power Scrub Deluxe FH50150 is ranked 1st while Rug Doctor Deep Carpet Cleaner is ranked 2nd. The most important reason people chose Hoover Power Scrub Deluxe FH50150 is:
This cleaner comes with a 2 year warranty.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro 2 year warranty
Rug doctor provides a two year warranty for this unit.
Pro Detachable hose panel
The Rug Doctor’s hose attaches to a panel on the back of the cleaner so it won’t get in your way when you don’t need it.
Pro Power cord won’t get in the way
The built-in holder is useful for keeping the extra-long extension cord in check.
Pro Can clean the edges of the carpet
This cleaner has bristles on the side of the unit so you can clean the edges of the carpet as well.
Pro Easy to store thanks to collapsible handle
Despite its size, it’s still relatively easy to store thanks to the collapsible handle.
Pro No need to constantly switch power outlets
The 28-foot long extension cord gives a lot of space for you to work without having to switch power outlets.
Pro Easily pushes through even thick carpets
The large wheels lets you push the carpet cleaner easily through very thick carpets.
Pro Great build quality
The Rug Doctor Deep Carpet Cleaner is an extremely well-built and sturdy machine that feels like a commercial-grade product. It’s a more massive and more rigid unit than ordinary consumer-grade carpet cleaners. The plastic parts and the connection joints are very solid and durable.
Pro Dries carpets quickly
With its powerful motor and 12-inch suction nozzle, it can dry the carpet in no time at all.
Pro Can spray extra detergent on heavy stains
For very tough stains, you can use the Super Boost feature to spray an extra spurt of detergent on an area with a very tough stain.
Pro Very effective at removing deep stains
The machine features a rotating and vibrating brush system powered by a powerful motor that’s very successful in getting rid of very deep stains that smaller and less powerful models fail to clean.
Pro 2 year warranty
This cleaner comes with a 2 year warranty.
Pro Comes with useful extensions
The unit comes with a few extensions for various specific uses such as a stair tool, an upholstery tool, and a crevice tool.
Pro Handy power cord handling
The built-in power cord holder lets you coil up the cables neatly after you’ve finished using the machine.
Pro Storage space for attachments included
The unit comes with a storage bag for the included attachments.
Pro Helpful heated air drying
The unit can dry the carpet more rapidly by blowing hot air on it. While it may not completely dry the carpet, it will definitely not be soaking wet.
Pro Smart detergent management
The water tank has a separate compartment for the detergent. This makes it easier to fill and empty the compartment as well as control just how much detergent you want to use.
Pro Easy to switch from wash mode to rinse mode
The unit has a knob that allows you to quickly switch between rinse and wash modes so you can have some flexibility on how you deal with stains.
Pro Easy to maneuver
Thanks to its lightweight design (it weights only 18 pounds), it’s easy to push around and the additional extensions lets it clean hard to reach spots.
Pro No need to constantly switch power outlets
Thanks to the 20-foot long power cord and 8-foot long extension hose, you can cover a wide area without moving the unit from one power outlet to another.
Pro Good for reaching awkward spots
The unit is very versatile in terms of reaching difficult corners. The included tools such as the crevice tool makes it simple to clean and suck up dirt from tight spots like underneath car seats.
Pro Great for handling tough stains
This cleaner has a system with plenty of brushes that move in a constant, 360-degree counter rotating motion. With these brushes, it can clean carpets deeper than cleaners without these brushes. This feature is exclusive to Hoover and is very efficient at removing deep dirt, debris, and pet stains. The brushes can be easily removed for cleaning.
Cons
Con Doesn’t hold much water
The 1 gallon tank will need refilling often if you need to cover a large area.
Con Has only one extension
The unit comes with only an upholstery tool. There is no crevice tool for cleaning narrow spaces.
Con Doesn’t heat up water
The unit doesn’t heat up water in the tank, so you have to remember to fill it up with hot water to get the best results.
Con Tricky to empty both tanks at the same time
The clean water tank and the dirty water tank don’t sync up very well, so you have to check the levels and add extra clean water before the dirty tank is full if you want to empty and fill the tanks simultaneously.
Con Has a learning curve to overcome
Unlike most consumer-grade carpet cleaners, where you push forward and pull backward to clean, this one requires you to clean only by pulling backwards. After each backward pass, you will need to tilt the machine and push it back to the front. This takes some time to get used to. On the other hand, if you have used professional-grade machines before, then this method is very similar and you will learn it quickly.
Con Not very portable
Weighing 25 pounds, the unit is heavier than other household-grade carpet cleaners, so it’s not easy to carry or move around.
Con Doesn’t heat up water
The unit doesn’t heat up water in the tank, so you need to fill it with hot water for cleaning.
Con Uneven liquid distribution
It tends to spray water unevenly, so some parts of the carpet can be more wet than others.
Con Needs to be refilled often
This unit needs to be refilled quite often, because of its small water tank. This can be quite annoying If you are planning to clean the whole house.
Con Ugly design
The machine looks bulky and very plasticky.
Con Unstable
Because of uneven weight distribution, the machine can be tipped over easily, with little force.