When comparing EdgeStar CWF340DZ vs Allavino VSWR172-2SSRN, the Slant community recommends EdgeStar CWF340DZ for most people. In the question“What are the best wine coolers?” EdgeStar CWF340DZ is ranked 5th while Allavino VSWR172-2SSRN is ranked 9th. The most important reason people chose EdgeStar CWF340DZ is:
This cooler has an interior blue LED light that makes it easy to see what’s inside the fridge.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Well lit on the inside
This cooler has an interior blue LED light that makes it easy to see what’s inside the fridge.
Pro Bottles can be kept away from children
The doors can be locked with an included key, keeping the bottles away from children.
Pro Reversible doors
The doors can be reversed to accommodate the space around the unit.
Pro Can handle large bottles
Because of its large dimensions, this wine cooler can store bottles that are longer than the standard 750ml ones.
Pro Wide temperature range
The unit can maintain temperatures between 41 °F up to 64 °F, meaning it’s suitable for storage of a wide range of wines with different needs.
Pro Bottles are easy to organize due to sliding racks
This cooler’s racks can be slid out to make the bottles easier to reach. Their wooden, further completing the high-end look of this device.
Pro Easy to use
The display and controls are easy to use and read, even in bright environments.
Pro Reliable and versatile cooling technology
While most modern wine coolers use thermoelectric cooling that are more efficient, this one uses a more traditional compressor type cooling. This technology has proven to be more reliable in the long term and compressors can work in a wider temperature range compared to thermoelectric ones.
Pro Elegant appearance
This wine cooler definitely looks more expensive than it is. The polished metal finish with the wooden trim slide out shelves looks and feels great. The blue LED lightning and control panel further complements the sleek appearance.
Pro Good for storing both red and white wine simultaneously
The unit has two independently controlled zones so you can store both red and white wines together. The upper zone can hold 12 standard 750ml wine bottles and its temperature range is best suited for white wines. The bottom can hold 22 bottles and is best used for red wines. The temperatures can be controlled precisely and slight fluctuations will not be a concern.
Pro Customizable handle
It comes with both a curved and a towel bar handle, so you can customize the unit to best suit your preferences.
Pro Great for serious collectors
The unit can hold up to 172 bottles. This should be enough even for serious wine collectors. Of course, the capacity may vary because some of the shelves allow you to store bigger bottles like champagne or oddly shaped wine bottles.
Pro Easy to program
The two independent-controlled cooling zones can be manually controlled. Alternatively, you can simply input the type of wine stored in the cooler and it will automatically adjust the temperatures in each zone to the most ideal ones.
Pro Can hold bottles of different shapes and sizes
The sturdy metal shelves are thin enough to get the maximum available storage space, yet strong enough to support the weight of many wine bottles. The shelves are designed in such a way that they can comfortably hold different shapes and sizes of bottles. They glide in and out smoothly using the ball-bearing tracks and feature stainless steel fronts and wooden slats for a sleek presentation.
Cons
Con One year warranty
The unit only comes with a standard one year warranty with no extended warranties for the compressor or other parts.
Con The key isn’t safe enough
While the key will do an excellent job of keeping children away from the bottles, it won’t be totally safe from committed attempts. That’s because the key is a standard hexagon shape and can be easily mimicked.
Con No UV protection
The glass on the door is not tinted, so it won’t protect your wine from UV radiation. This isn’t much of a worry indoors, unless the unit is directly exposed to sunlight.
Con Noisy
Since the unit uses a compressor instead of thermoelectric cooling, it can be quite noisy. The noise is about the same as a small fridge.
Con Not very good at preventing temperature fluctuations
The temperatures can fluctuate a bit on the upper zone. Although it only deviates by a couple of degrees, it’s still something to consider if you need your temperatures to be precise.
Con Needs some free space around it
The unit needs a couple of inches of free space around, for ventilation, it so you can’t build it in counters.
Con Not easy to move
The unit is heavy for its size. At 100 pounds, it’s not easy to move around.
Con Not the quietest unit
The ventilation of this unit is located at the front, so it’s louder than units with ventilation at the back. Still, it shouldn’t be louder than a standard refrigerator.