When comparing NewAir AW-321ED vs Allavino VSWR172-2SSRN, the Slant community recommends NewAir AW-321ED for most people. In the question“What are the best wine coolers?” NewAir AW-321ED is ranked 4th while Allavino VSWR172-2SSRN is ranked 9th. The most important reason people chose NewAir AW-321ED is:
This unit's shelves are wooden, so the bottle will not get scratched, as it would happen with metal shelves.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Bottles won't get scratched by shelves
This unit's shelves are wooden, so the bottle will not get scratched, as it would happen with metal shelves.
Pro Quieter and more eco than compressor cooling
The unit uses a thermoelectric cooling system which is quieter and more eco friendly compared to compressor-based systems.
Pro Stores equal amount of red and white wines
The majority of dual zone wine coolers can store less white wines instead of red wines. This isn’t the case with this wine cooler as it can equally store 16 bottles in each cooling zone.
Pro Customizable handle
It comes with both a curved and a towel bar handle, so you can customize the unit to best suit your preferences.
Pro Great for serious collectors
The unit can hold up to 172 bottles. This should be enough even for serious wine collectors. Of course, the capacity may vary because some of the shelves allow you to store bigger bottles like champagne or oddly shaped wine bottles.
Pro Easy to program
The two independent-controlled cooling zones can be manually controlled. Alternatively, you can simply input the type of wine stored in the cooler and it will automatically adjust the temperatures in each zone to the most ideal ones.
Pro Can hold bottles of different shapes and sizes
The sturdy metal shelves are thin enough to get the maximum available storage space, yet strong enough to support the weight of many wine bottles. The shelves are designed in such a way that they can comfortably hold different shapes and sizes of bottles. They glide in and out smoothly using the ball-bearing tracks and feature stainless steel fronts and wooden slats for a sleek presentation.
Cons
Con Fans need cleaning every once in a while
There are air filters installed on the fans that you have to clean once every couple of months so the fans don’t get blocked. Generally, it’s easy to do if you can access the back of the cooler.
Con Not great for large parkling wine bottles
It has trouble storing large sparkling wine bottles, but it's worth noting it wasn’t designed for sparkling wines in the first place.
Con Thermoelectric cooling has some limitations
This cooler uses thermoelectric cooling, which is ambient temperature sensitive and will work best between 50-80 degrees Fahrenheit. If it’s lower or higher, the unit will struggle in maintaining the desired temperatures. The unit can maintain temperatures between 46 to 66 degrees Fahrenheit which is enough for red and white wines, but not ideal for sparkling wines that need temperatures as low as 40 degrees.
Con Not the quietest unit
The ventilation of this unit is located at the front, so it’s louder than units with ventilation at the back. Still, it shouldn’t be louder than a standard refrigerator.