When comparing TorGuard vs Roll your own VPN, the Slant community recommends TorGuard for most people. In the question“What is the best VPN provider? ” TorGuard is ranked 4th while Roll your own VPN is ranked 62nd. The most important reason people chose TorGuard is:
When using a VPN, a DNS leak occurs when traffic originating from the computer isn't routed through the VPN's servers. Instead, traffic is routed through unprotected servers posing a great risk to the user's privacy. TorGuard offers a service that detects DNS leaking, regardless of which VPN is being used.
Question Ranking
Pros
Pro Takes DNS leaking seriously
When using a VPN, a DNS leak occurs when traffic originating from the computer isn't routed through the VPN's servers. Instead, traffic is routed through unprotected servers posing a great risk to the user's privacy. TorGuard offers a service that detects DNS leaking, regardless of which VPN is being used.
Pro Specific types of servers for different activities
TorGuard offers servers geared towards different activities. There are torrent friendly servers, encryption friendly servers, and more.
Pro A variety of protocols
Such as http/socks proxies, OpenVPN, SSH Tunnels, SSTP VPN and Stealth VPN.
Pro No logs are kept
TorGuard does not record user activity, including logs and timestamps. This ensures total anonymity.
Pro Multiple payment methods
Payments are accepted through all forms of credit or debit card, PayPal, OKPAY, and Bitcoin.
Pro Fast
No apparent slowdown compared to accessing the Internet without a VPN.
Pro Great pricing
As low as $5/mo with regular coupon codes.
Pro Single IP
Quite often with VPN services you get a shared IP, here you get one all to yourself. This means you are far less likely to be blocked.
Pro Cheap
Depending on your use case, a cheap unmetered VPS can cost very little.
Pro You control everything
"Is there logging?" "Do I get my own IP?" So many questions, easily answered by running your own service!
Cons
Con Requires your personal info when signing up
Requiring personal information for sign up can be a conflict of interest in a service that claims to offer total anonymity.
Con Doesn’t respond to request for refunds
Con BitTorrent is only allowed selectively
Con Frequent hiccups
Con One location only
Unless you set up multiple boxes, you have to think about where you are getting your server. The advantage of many VPN services is that you can pick your location to get around geo-blocks.
Con Tougher to set up
OpenVPN in particular is not exactly trivial to set up.