When comparing PumpUp vs Fitocracy, the Slant community recommends Fitocracy for most people. In the question“What are the best fitness apps for iOS?” Fitocracy is ranked 2nd while PumpUp is ranked 8th. The most important reason people chose Fitocracy is:
Earn points, unlock achievements, take on challenges and quests and level up. Seeing progress, getting rewarded for activities and reaching a set threshold feels nice and helps in continuing to be motivated. Especially when just starting out. There's even a leaderboard so you can compare your progress to your friends.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Customized workouts
The user chooses their goals, amount of time they plan to exercise, available equipment and more. PumpUp then builds the customized workouts, including providing video demonstrations.
Pro Well designed and easy to use interface
The PumpUp interface has a beautiful clean and modern design. It's design is extremely user-friendly and intuitive to use.
Pro Gamification keeps you motivated
Earn points, unlock achievements, take on challenges and quests and level up. Seeing progress, getting rewarded for activities and reaching a set threshold feels nice and helps in continuing to be motivated. Especially when just starting out.
There's even a leaderboard so you can compare your progress to your friends.
Pro Engaging community
You can post updates on progress and have other people comment on it, encouraging to keep working out. You can ask questions and a community of more than 1 million users will be there to answer.
Pro Free
There is a paid option ($4.99/mo or $44.99/yr), called Hero, that adds private messaging, ability to challenge a friend in an activity, assign yourself a title and weekly insights among other things.
Pro Workout logging UI is very simple & clean to use
Pro Versatility
Fitocracy has solutions for all manners of workout regimens and styles.
Cons
Con Can be harmful to those with poor self-esteem
PumpUp is like Instagram for fitness, which results in an endless feed of often athletic bodies. For those who harm their self-esteem by comparing themselves to others, this app may not be ideal.