When comparing Pixi Particles vs PopcornFX, the Slant community recommends PopcornFX for most people. In the question“What are the best particle editors?” PopcornFX is ranked 1st while Pixi Particles is ranked 2nd. The most important reason people chose PopcornFX is:
Aside from the editors within the engine plugins, PopcornFX also includes an external editor which allows the user more freedom with their particles.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Interactive editor available
Pixi has an editor available which makes it super easy to create and customize your particles. The editor exports your settings to a JSON file which you can then load into your project for the Pixi Particle library to use.
You can check the editor out here.
Pro Great for browser games
Pixi is a particle system library built for the PixiJS library (a WebGL renderer), which makes it ideal for a browser based game.
Pro Custom particle images
Pixi allows for importing custom particle images, meaning you can create your own graphics.
Pro Simple interface on the editor
Pixi's interface is just a simple web page. All of your tools on the right, and your preview in the center. Nothing is buried or hidden in menus, so finding the variable you want to change is incredibly easy.
Pro External editor included
Aside from the editors within the engine plugins, PopcornFX also includes an external editor which allows the user more freedom with their particles.
Pro Tree based architecture
PopcornFX, unlike a lot of other particle effects tools, is editable from a tree (a lot like layers in Photoshop) rather than a set of nodes. This removes a lot of complexity from editing your particles, while still retaining all the control you have with a node system.
Pro Includes Unity and Unreal Engine plugins
PopcornFX comes with plugins for both Unity and the Unreal Engine, which cuts down on the workload of generating particle systems by allowing you to do them in-engine.
Cons
Con Requires PixiJS
PixiJS is a great web renderer, but if you don't want to use it in your project, then you won't be able to use Pixi Particles.
Con 2d particles only
