When comparing onlykey vs My Login Vault, the Slant community recommends My Login Vault for most people. In the question“What are the best offline password managers?” My Login Vault is ranked 18th while onlykey is ranked 27th. The most important reason people chose My Login Vault is:
You can add an unlimited number of logins and categories, in order to make organizing passwords easy.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Completely offline (separate hardware)
Pro Stores 2FA
FIDO U2F, Google Auth TOTP, Yubikey OTP.
Pro Can be used for secure messages with Keybase PGP
Pro Open Source
Pro Unlimited logins and categories
You can add an unlimited number of logins and categories, in order to make organizing passwords easy.
Pro Privacy options
Privacy options, such as auto shutdown, prevents access when you leave your desk by never showing passwords, unless you ask it to.
Pro Choice of style
A credit card for the wallet or key ring for keys allows the user to visually see differences in their accounts.
Pro All data is stored offline
The app does not call home, ever, as it is a non cloud-based app. It encrypts and stores the data on the users USB.
Pro Simple to use
Easy to use for non techies.
Pro No recurring fees
There is no monthly or yearly fee, and you get a years worth of free updates.
Cons
Con Does not sync over devices
This is an offline app (non cloud based), it only works on Windows PCs and does not sync with your mobile, for example.
Con May be too simple for techies
Ideal for the average computer user, but maybe not enough options for the more techie individual, as there is no browser integration.
Con No multiple users
Only suitable for one user.