When comparing Saladin vs Direttore File Manager, the Slant community recommends Saladin for most people. In the question“What are the best file managers for Windows?” Saladin is ranked 26th while Direttore File Manager is ranked 36th.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Bookmark support
Pro Built-in file viewer
Which even supports a lot of encodings.
Pro Open source
GPL v3.
Pro Intuitive usable
All commands use the well-known shortcuts.
Pro Lynx-like motion
Cursor left: parent directory, cursor right: go into directory/zip.
Pro White and dark theme
Pro Column View Superior to Macintosh Finder
Direttore got it right. The other alternatives with a column view option ("miller columns") are unwieldy and ascetically offensive.
Pro Totally Themable
I can change colors, button,scrollbars. I also changed the icons for folders and some file-types. Info on Direttore webpage.
Pro Color labels
Ntfs drives only, but still very convenient.
Cons
Con Blocking file operations
E.g. while moving a large directory structure, you can't do anything else.