When comparing Vanilla Music vs Phonograph Music Player, the Slant community recommends Vanilla Music for most people. In the question“What are the best audio players for Android?” Vanilla Music is ranked 2nd while Phonograph Music Player is ranked 4th.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Open-source
Pro Ad-free
Pro Free
Pro Display Japanese characters correctly
Pro Highly customizable player
Unlike other Android media players currently available, Phonograph Music Player can allow users to customize their player with more than 100+ colors.
Pro Free
This app is completely free without any ads. However, there is a donation option available.
Pro Integration with Last.fm
Phonograph Music Player supports integration with the official Last.fm app, which allows users to scrobble the music they are currently listening to.
Pro Build-in tag editor
Phonograph Music Player comes with build-in tag editor that can allow users to edit the MP3 tag / metadata.
Pro Auto retrieve artists images
Phonograph Music Player can automatically retrieve images of artists directly from Last.fm.
Cons
Con Strictly offline
No cloud & network based playback.