When comparing Garmin Vivosmart HR - Large Fit vs Fitbit Alta Fitness Tracker, X-Large, the Slant community recommends Garmin Vivosmart HR - Large Fit for most people. In the question“What are the best fitness trackers for large wrists?” Garmin Vivosmart HR - Large Fit is ranked 2nd while Fitbit Alta Fitness Tracker, X-Large is ranked 3rd. The most important reason people chose Garmin Vivosmart HR - Large Fit is:
Although it can use two bands, one regular size and one extra large, they are adjustable just like a watch, so it allows the HR to fit in almost any wrist. The main straps are soft and flexible.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro The band is changeable, XL size is available
Although it can use two bands, one regular size and one extra large, they are adjustable just like a watch, so it allows the HR to fit in almost any wrist. The main straps are soft and flexible.
Pro Waterproof
That gives it an edge over Fitbits, which are not waterproof). You can use it while showering, swimming, snorkeling and diving into open water.
Pro Plenty of notification functions
It can notify you of incoming emails, phone calls, text and calendar reminders from your phone. It has a function for setting and following team goals. It warns you by vibrating if it detects you have been inactive for a long period of time. It has a "find my phone" feature. It can read entire text messages and has horizontal and vertical screen orientation.
Pro It provides you with sleep metrics
This fitness tracker can also track the depth of your sleep, and it gets the exact time you fall asleep and wake spot-on.
Pro The charging port is also waterproofed
Most micro-USB or USB-C charging ports on waterproofed devices eventually develop leakage over the long term. This device has a propietary charging port, designed to ensure that the unit remains waterproof in the long run.
Pro It has a battery conservation function
To help conserve its battery, each time you are resting, your heart rate will be read every 5 minutes instead of every second.
Pro A companion app
The Fitbit companion app is incredibly resourceful, easy to use, and is compatible with every other Fitbit device. All you have to do is download it, link it with the tracker and you are good to go. The app’s interface makes it possible to effortlessly and seamlessly adjust your workout schedule, water intake goals and even sleep patterns. And if you are the kind that likes sifting through settings, there is much to accomplish on the app.
Pro User-friendly Interface
Familiarizing yourself with the tracker’s interface should not take you long. Its default screen indicate time. Depending on the selected face, your overall progress and date of the exercise might also be indicated on the home screen. It is also very easy to switch between calories burned, distance covered, steps taken and spent time Fitbit’s mobile app. The order of these pages can also be toggled to determine the order in which they appear on the interface. For instance, if you rather see the calories burned, you can change it to become your home screen.
Pro Long Battery Life
The Fitbit Alto battery life is a force to be reckoned with. According to the manufacturer’s website, it can last for an impressive 5 full days and nights under constant use without the need to recharge
Pro Call, Text & Calendar Alerts
Understandably, you might want to keep your phone out of sight so that you can concentrate on your fitness goals. Nevertheless, this does not imply that you would not like to receive text, calls and calendar alerts. To compensate for this, the Alto operates over Bluetooth 4.0 which facilitates a seamless connection with your phone. Notifications are made possible via a vibration motor which buzzes to notify you of incoming texts, calls and most importantly to celebrate when you reach your fitness goals.
Pro SmartTrack technology
Beneath the screen, the Alta is fitted with an accelerometer which automatically detects your daily exercise activities and syncs them with the Fitbit mobile app to enable you to track your progress during and after exercises. And if you don’t like the inconveniences of handling your smartphone when working out, live progress can be tracked via the tracker’s screen but it has to be tapped first to become active. Nevertheless, it is important to note that it does not turn on a single tap. Sometimes you will have to double tap it for it to awaken. The face of the tracker is also highly customizable. It boasts 5 horizontal and 5 vertical positions. The choice here depends on where you find it easiest to access the screen from. It also switches on automatically whenever you flip your wrist on a time checking position.
Pro Track all day activities
If you are after a fitness tracker that can track most of your daily exercise activities, the Fitbit Alto will come in handy. It is designed to track your steps, distance covered, sleep, calories burned, active exercise time and stationary time using a 3 axis accelerometer.
Pro Adjustable & customizable wristband
Bearing in mind that you are out for a fitness tracker that will fit on a large wrist, you will be pleased to learn that the Fitbit Alta is designed just for that. I mean, the wristbands are customizable. To be precise, it comes with customizable straps which can also be replaced with third-party bands or adjusted to virtually fit on any wrist size. Even better, switching out the bands is pretty easy. You only need to slide and push the quick release button to adjust or replace it with whichever band cozily fits on your wrist and pleases your eyes. This high level of customizability not only gives you the autonomy to choose a comfortable band size but also the freedom to swap your brand and switch up your style. Being compatible with leather, metal and classic themed bands from the world’s leading fashion designers, you can count on this iconic tracker to create a look that best fits your occasion.
Cons
Con The move notifications can get annoying
You can turn them off, but they will be on again after your established sleep time ends.
Con It has a hard time tracking stair steps
The unit has a barometric altimeter to help it track stair steps, but in some situations, it is just not accurate enough. For example, it sometimes gets triggered by elevators and other times it fails to count some stair steps.
Con Heart rate monitor often inaccurate
Heart rate should always be a linear progression up and a smooth movement down, and this specific model always shows some noise when compared to chest straps like the Polar H7. The noise stabilizes over a 3 mins time, meaning that the reads of both products will eventually be very close, but there is always bound to be some jumping around at first.
Con Not waterproof
The tracker is not designed to be waterproof. For this reason, it might limit you when it comes to doing water bond activities such as swimming.
Con Can’t handle intense tracking
Runners and athletes looking for a tracker that can handle intense tracking will have to look elsewhere since the Fitbit Alto does not come with extra features such as optical heart monitor, stair climbing monitor or GPS.
Con The screen can be unresponsive
Though the tracker’s screen can be used to track progress, it can be frustrating at times because it is not very responsive. It might take a few hard taps to show.