When comparing TestCaseLab vs XQual XStudio, the Slant community recommends XQual XStudio for most people. In the question“What are the best tools for test case management?” XQual XStudio is ranked 5th while TestCaseLab is ranked 7th. The most important reason people chose XQual XStudio is:
XStudio has a free comunity edition available for up to 4 users and 200 tests.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Cheap
Pro Easy to use
Pro User friendly
Pro Detailed reports
Pro Integrations
Has integrations with commonly used tools (Redmine, Jira, Pivotal, YouTrack, Asana, Trello, Mantis).
Pro Saves time
Allows doing less routine work comparing to the usual test case management methods (google/excel spreadsheets or the other tool).
Pro Clean UI
Has no needless clicks.
Pro Great support
The Testcaselab team hears suggestions and implement the features that users ask each month.
Pro Unlimited users, pay only for test cases

Pro Free community edition available
XStudio has a free comunity edition available for up to 4 users and 200 tests.
Pro Can interface with any automation framework, even proprietary
XQual provides more than 50 drivers to interface with all the automation tools in the market but also an SDK that gives the ability to develop ones own if they have a proprietary framework for instance.
Pro Nice design
The GUI is really nice and easy to use for a such complete product. Usually, when you have all those features (ability to drive automated tests, parametrization etc.) this becomes quickly messy. No problem here... it's very clean and nicely designed.
Cons
Con No requirements management
Con No reporting yet
Con Supports only one way integrations
Integrations with external systems (for example Jira) are only one-way. This means that while you can submit bugs which will be tracked by Jira, changes in Jira itself are not fed back to XStudio.
Alternative Products
