When comparing Gemcraft: Chasing Shadows vs Bloons TD Battles, the Slant community recommends Gemcraft: Chasing Shadows for most people. In the question“What are the best PC Tower Defense games?” Gemcraft: Chasing Shadows is ranked 6th while Bloons TD Battles is ranked 26th. The most important reason people chose Gemcraft: Chasing Shadows is:
The main mechanic of the game is using gems that provide properties like splash damage, poison, chain lightning, etc to your towers in different combinations. Add to that the fact that there are 7 levels for each gem, you have to manage your mana, there are multiple difficulty levels that change the amount of experience you gain, there are multiple kinds of spells, 25 passive skills and talisman fragments among other variables that you have to balance and you end up with an impressive amount of choice and depth.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Addictive, in-depth gameplay based on combining gems that provide different traits to your towers
The main mechanic of the game is using gems that provide properties like splash damage, poison, chain lightning, etc to your towers in different combinations. Add to that the fact that there are 7 levels for each gem, you have to manage your mana, there are multiple difficulty levels that change the amount of experience you gain, there are multiple kinds of spells, 25 passive skills and talisman fragments among other variables that you have to balance and you end up with an impressive amount of choice and depth.
Pro More than 140 levels
With so many levels to play in the game will last a good while. Each map is varied and with that makes for an experience that does not get tiring either.
Pro Lots of players make queue times short
One of the make or break aspects of tower defenses is whether there's anyone to play with, and Bloons TD Battles has that in spades. There are very few times where you have to wait more than 30 seconds for a battle, even when it's a mode that almost everyone has forgotten about.
Pro Multiplayer
Unlike most tower defense games, this game is full on multiplayer. They have a unique system of economy that incentives sending enemies, but you also have to know when to store up resources for defense, or big rushes.
Pro Updated often
Bloons TD Battles is updated fairly often, and has had new game modes come out every couple of months. They adapt to what people like and dislike, and base updates partly on that, while adding ideas of their own.
Cons
Con Can seem too heavily luck based
Hit damage is luck based meaning that it is up to the game at points as to how much damage is given making for a bit of an imbalance when winning in just a few strikes in one game and then having to do many hits in another.