When comparing Superdesk vs Netlify CMS, the Slant community recommends Netlify CMS for most people. In the question“What are the best open source headless CMS's?” Netlify CMS is ranked 6th while Superdesk is ranked 10th. The most important reason people chose Netlify CMS is:
Experimental support for GitHub's GraphQL API is now available for the GitHub backend. Without mutation.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Visual
The interface is clean and well designed. You can tell someone with a UX background worked on it and not just software engineers.
Pro Easy to use
Putting together an article is straightforward: you type the text into the main fields and then use drag and drop to add photos.
Pro Publish to more than one website
You have the option of setting up publishing routes to choose where something gets published in case you have multiple websites.
Pro Customizable
I like that you can set up a personal workspace and also add different widgets to your dashboard depending on what you’re interested in.
Pro Newsroom automation
Superdesk can aggregate and automate multiple mundane newsroom jobs.
Pro Experimental support for GitHub's GraphQL API
Experimental support for GitHub's GraphQL API is now available for the GitHub backend. Without mutation.
Pro Easy Creating Custom Widgets option
The NetlifyCMS exposes a window.CMS global object that you can use to register custom widgets, previews, and editor plugins. The same object is also the default export if you import Netify CMS as an npm module. The available widget extension methods are listed here.
Pro Modern
Pro Open-source
Pro Built in React.js
Cons
Con Sometimes buggy
Sometimes, when trying to publish a post I was getting errors which was a bit annoying. However, after we updated to the latest version the instance was running smoothly.
Con Not one-click publishing
At least in our company’s system you need to do a couple of extra steps to publish an article.
Con A lot of configuration
Example: a few plugins and some code are needed for gatsby-img or markdown to work.