When comparing Official Android SDK Emulator w/HAXM vs Visual Studio Emulator for Android, the Slant community recommends Official Android SDK Emulator w/HAXM for most people. In the question“What are the best ways to run/emulate Android on a PC?” Official Android SDK Emulator w/HAXM is ranked 2nd while Visual Studio Emulator for Android is ranked 12th.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pro Accelerometer support
Pro Flexible interface
Pro Works on Windows/Mac/Linux
Pro Libre/Open source
Pro Various power characteristics can be emulated
Via the power command, AC charging state as well as battery state, presence, health and capacity can be changed.
Pro LCD density can be abstracted
Pro GPS emulation support
Longitute, latitude and altitude information can be supplied to the device once it's running. NMEA 1083 formatting is optional.
Pro Can simulate complex network environments
Each running instance of the emulator has a separate virtual router allowing complex simulations and setups. Network speed and delay can be simulated either by using presets for various network formats or manually entering desired values. It's even possible to interconnect one AVD to another AVD.
Pro The virtual device is capable of recording and playing back audio
Pro Camera support
Pro Allows sending an SMS to the virtual device
You can send an SMS using the command
sms send <senderPhoneNumber> <textmessage>
Pro GSM emulated modem allows telephony emulation
Telephony emulation allows simulating incoming calls as well as establishing and terminating data connections. Calls can be accepted, but there's no support for call audio.
Pro SD card emulation support
A disk image can be loaded into the emulator on startup to act as an SD card. This can be done via AVD Manager or mksdcard utility. While the SD card cannot be removed from a running emulator, files can still be moved, copied to and from, and removed from the card. The SD card can be of any size up to 128GB.
Pro Easy to set up and use
Install devices in two clicks, very intuitive interface for simulations.
Pro Simulates many scenarios
Location/GPS (including live journeying), Camera (using webcam or image file from PC), Accelerometer, Networking (bandwidth and signal strength), etc.
All features are free.
Runs using Hyper-V, the built-in virtualization technology in Windows, so it's very fast (like a real device).
Con Setting up the whole environment is a hassle
Con Clunky UI around things like GPS and such
Con Bad OS X support
Con Can't place actual phone calls
While simulated phone calls can be placed and received, there's no call audio support.
Con No Bluetooth support
Con Only runs on Hyper-V capable machines
Has to be Win8+ pro edition or higher. No Mac or Linux support yet.