When comparing Tuft & Needle vs Amerisleep AS2, the Slant community recommends Amerisleep AS2 for most people. In the question“What are the best foam mattresses?” Amerisleep AS2 is ranked 2nd while Tuft & Needle is ranked 3rd. The most important reason people chose Amerisleep AS2 is:
This mattress has a medium-firm feel that's softer than most mattresses made for the plus sized. So it's comfortable to sleep on but still gives the support a heavy body needs. Most mattresses made for people weighing more than 250 pounds are too firm and uncomfortable.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Cool to sleep on
This is great for those who don't like the heat associated with memory foam mattresses. The adaptive foam top layer uses heat wicking graphite and cooling gel. These materials pull the heat from you and transfer it away from your body. It also has a breathable fabric which helps it from trapping heat. And since you won't sink into the mattress, you won't end up heated and sweaty while you sleep.
Pro Comfortable for most sleeping positions
Unlike other foams, this mattress won't feel like you're sinking on quicksand. It's comfortable enough to sleep on and relieves pressure on your body. But it isn't too soft due to the 3-inch top layer of adaptive foam.
Pro Good body support
This mattress doesn't come with any size or weight limits. The more pressure you apply, the more it cradles your body. It has a 7-inch support layer so you're provided with adequate amount of firmness to bear and hold your weight up. As a result, it doesn't let you sink in too deep.
Pro Unique adaptive foam
Great for those who like the benefits of memory and latex foams. The Tuft & Needle adaptive foam doesn't carry their negative attributes. It's a product resulting from listening to various customer feedback. As a result, the foam is unique to Tuft & needle alone.
Pro Compatible to most bed frames
You'll be able to use this mattress on most box springs, slatted or adjustable frames. This saves you money since you can use the bed frame you already have.
Pro Great value for money
This mattress is worth considering especially if you're on a budget. It only has a starting price of $325 but it carries a lot of nice features.
Pro Risk-free trial
This mattress comes with a 100-night free trial period. You can sleep on it and actually see if it's the right mattress for you. If not, you can get a refund and they will remove your mattress free of charge and donate it to a charity of your choice.
Pro Comfortable to sleep on for plus-sized persons
This mattress has a medium-firm feel that's softer than most mattresses made for the plus sized. So it's comfortable to sleep on but still gives the support a heavy body needs. Most mattresses made for people weighing more than 250 pounds are too firm and uncomfortable.
Pro Promotes good blood circulation which eases muscle pain
Its Celliant cover promotes good blood circulation which eases muscle pain or soreness because it has been scientifically proven to increase oxygenation in the body which can reduce body pain. Celliant is a fabric made with 13 thermoreactive minerals that convert your body's heat into beneficial infrared energy.
Pro Very responsive when changing positions
The mattress gives a less "stuck" feeling when sleeping on it because it bounces back to its original shape in seconds and doesn't retain the previous body shape.
Pro Free to try for 100 nights
Even if you're undecided, this mattress can be tried for a hundred nights and can be returned if not completely satisfied. A full refund will be given and the used mattress donated to a local charity or recycled.
Pro Easy to fit through your door
It's delivered to you compressed and contained inside a box. A twin mattress that measures 38" x 74" x 12" is shipped in a 15" x 15" x 42" box weighing 54 pounds. A king sized mattress that is 76" x 80" x 12" comes in only a 19" x 19" x 42" box that weighs 116 pounds.
Pro Good for stomach/back sleepers, and those experiencing back pain when lying down
This mattress contains a foam layer with zones that redistributes pressure well. Key areas like the shoulder and lower back get the proper amount of support it needs.
Cons
Con Too firm for side sleepers
If you like sleeping on your side, you might find this mattress a bit hard and uncomfortable.
Con Too firm for side sleepers
Since the mattress has a medium to firm foam quality, it may not be soft enough to decrease the amount of shoulder and hip pressure when you sleep on your side, which can leave you with a feeling of discomfort and even soreness.
Con Too warm
Despite its open cell structure, its memory foam composition, which is known to retain body heat, may get to be too hot and uncomfortable when sleeping in warm weather or for a long period of time.