When comparing Timing for Mac vs Time Doctor, the Slant community recommends Timing for Mac for most people. In the question“What are the best time tracking apps for freelancers?” Timing for Mac is ranked 10th while Time Doctor is ranked 16th. The most important reason people chose Timing for Mac is:
No start/stop timers, no forgetting to track time.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Fully automatic
No start/stop timers, no forgetting to track time.
Pro Easy time analysis after the fact
once a users day is finished they can go through the history of the app to pick and choose what tasks are worth keeping for time tracking of the day. This makes it easy in the sense that there is no manual tracking needed to be done, everything is recorded and then can be filtered down to the users work tasks.
Pro No Subscription Needed
The app works completely offline - no user data leaves your computer and you don't have to pay some monthly fee.
Pro Easy to use and great UI
You can start tracking time in just 1 click. Also the reports are really useful to track productivity and improvements.
Pro Time Doctor tracks work hours and productivity
Excellent at productivity and time monitoring. The desktop client is discreet, the web-based reports are very accurate.
Pro Has email notifications
Users can set up email notifications through the app in order to get activity reports send at certain intervals.
Pro All data encrypted
Everything that is sent to Time Doctor's servers is encrypted, so no worries about security.
Cons
Con Only works on one device, no billing, no syncing and no mobile or web apps
Timing has a pretty limited use for a paid app as it only works on one Mac device. There is no cloud sync to get the schedules synced to another device. There is also no billing built into the app.
Con Mac only
Is only compatible with OSX, so is pretty limiting in that regard.
Con Expensive
At $10 a month there are cheaper solutions out there for employee monitoring and time tracking.