When comparing AutomateIt vs Automagic, the Slant community recommends Automagic for most people. In the question“What are the best Android apps for making your phone automatically perform certain actions based on set criteria?” Automagic is ranked 7th while AutomateIt is ranked 8th.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pro Rules can be shared
There's a catalog of Rules uploaded by other users that you can browse and download.
Pro Easy to use
Very simple user interface.
Pro No noticeable effect on battery
Pro Works perfectly out of the box
Not all similar apps deliver what they say. This one just works.
Pro Free version
Though there is a paid version of the app, the free version can be sufficient to satisfy basic automation needs.
Pro Live view of executing flows
It's easier than Tasker to me.
Pro Flows can be defined graphically like a flowchart
Pro Plug in
It supports all the plug in which supports Tasker.
Pro Better programming
Some flows work better than Tasker. In fact, some tests that often don't in Tasker do so easily in Automagic.
Pro Less or no dependency
It doesn't need an app like 'auto voice' or something like this of Tasker app.
Pro Scripting language is superior
This app has a much more intuitive scripting language with tons of snippets and function examples. More powerful, elegant, flexible, and seems less resource intense.
Con Developer unresponsive
No development activities evident since 2017
Con You are forced to draw out flow diagrams
Pretty, but at the end of the day a pain to maintain diagram readability AND logic.
Con Not popular
It's not as popular as Tasker.