When comparing Shadowrun vs Vampire: The Masquerade, the Slant community recommends Vampire: The Masquerade for most people. In the question“What are the best tabletop RPGs?” Vampire: The Masquerade is ranked 6th while Shadowrun is ranked 23rd. The most important reason people chose Vampire: The Masquerade is:
The emphasis of the game is to create drama and intrigue. The Hunger mechanic is central to the experience, and characters have strong, in depth motivations and drives.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro In-depth character creation
Pro Alternative experience to most other action-adventure based RPGs
The emphasis of the game is to create drama and intrigue. The Hunger mechanic is central to the experience, and characters have strong, in depth motivations and drives.
Pro Great connection to overall lore
Role-playing oriented system.
Cons
Con Character creation can take a long time
Con Urban Fantasy isn't for everyone
Con Role playing oriented system requires a GM that is well informed of the world and lore
Con Edgelord Magnet
Game is perfect for high school theater geeks
Con Not for kids
Definitely adult orientated material - may not be to everybody’s taste and includes themes that may not be appropriate to children.