When comparing Soldat vs Alien Swarm, the Slant community recommends Alien Swarm for most people. In the question“What are the best LAN party PC games?” Alien Swarm is ranked 29th while Soldat is ranked 70th. The most important reason people chose Alien Swarm is:
The game consists of tried-and-true top-down shooter mechanics that will be familiar to most players; it is reminiscent of older arcade and console shooters.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Runs on basically all machines
Pro Suitable for large parties
Up to 32 players can be supported in one game, making for a great party game where many players can join in on the same match.
Pro Tiny download
Pro Easy to pick up and play, even for beginners
The game consists of tried-and-true top-down shooter mechanics that will be familiar to most players; it is reminiscent of older arcade and console shooters.
Pro Anyone can download and play the game as it is free-to-play and open-source
The game is completely free and has no microtransactions or ads.
The source code is also free and accessible, so the game can be easily modded.
Pro Easily play with up to 4-players in online co-op
Alien Swarm allows for up to 4-player online co-op, which makes for an easy way to play with a small group of friends or strangers.
Pro Convenient offline LAN support
Alien Swarm offers offline LAN (local area network) support, meaning that the game can be easily played locally with each machine connected together in the same place.
Cons
Con Buggy with poor design
This is a community made game that may have some issues, such as crashing. The menu system is also a pain to navigate and could be better designed.
Con Can get a bit repetitive
The gameplay doesn't change much from mission to mission; you’re generally just shooting aliens over and over again.
Con Gameplay is too short
The main story only takes about three or four hours to complete, which means you could beat the game in one sitting pretty easily.