When comparing Gandi vs POP.co, the Slant community recommends Gandi for most people. In the question“What are the best domain name registrars/providers?” Gandi is ranked 3rd while POP.co is ranked 14th.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pro Best in basic features
Pro Private Whois registration is included
Private whois registration is provided without any extra charges.
Pro All-inclusive package
Pro Two-factor authentication
Pro Programmatic API support.
Pro Free unlimited subdomains
Pro Free email forwarding
Pro Free web mail
Pro Strong Anti-SOPA stance
Gandi took a stand against SOPA.
Pro Access levels and delegating is easy
Pro Quick and easy way to get online
POP sets you up in less than 60 seconds with everything you need to get a new idea or business online - the setup is quick and there is no credit card required.
Pro Free custom email address
To get immediate credibility for your idea, you can email potential customers/partners from your own custom email address, using your domain name. Most registrars charge for this, but the first address is free with POP. You have to use webmail (or you can upgrade to IMAP access for $1/mo), but as a free service, it's a great feature to help gain traction before adding costs to a budding idea!
Pro Two free website editors included: Simple Page and Weebly
Every domain registered with POP includes a choice from Simple Page WYSIWYG editor or Weebly.
Pro Free WHOIS privacy for applicable domains
POP proudly offers free WHOIS privacy for all registered domains whose TLDs allow for it.
Con Can be perceived as lacking professionalism due to the blunt "no bullshit" tagline
At face value, Gandi's "no bullshit" marketing slogan and tone may be perceived as unprofessional, especially in the eyes of corporate or otherwise sensitive clients of yours.
Con No automatic renewal
No automatic renewal unless with pre-paid money (which makes little sense, as one can register for a few years).
Con Whois protection doesn't hide the name
Con No catch all email forwarding
Gandi does not support wildcard email forwarding for undefined addresses.