When comparing SolForge vs Magic 2015, the Slant community recommends Magic 2015 for most people. In the question“What are the best digital Collectible Card Games on PC?” Magic 2015 is ranked 21st while SolForge is ranked 25th. The most important reason people chose Magic 2015 is:
The core of the Magic games is extremely deep with years of additions, tweaks and new rules to broaden the scope of the whole game.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Simple rules but plenty of strategy to be found
The rules of the game are pretty easy to learn but it is underlying strategy of what decks to build and what playstyles to use that make the game so strategic.
Pro Unique idea for game mechanics
No mana, play two cards per turn to level them up and increase their power, every four turns the deck is reshuffled to include the leveled up cards.
Pro Active and awesome community
Small community, but very active and dedicated to the survival of this game.
Pro Cross platform accounts
SolForge has cross platform accounts, making it easy for users to load up the game on their preferred device and log into their account with all of their progress.
Pro Deep gaming experience
The core of the Magic games is extremely deep with years of additions, tweaks and new rules to broaden the scope of the whole game.
Pro Six tutorials to help players learn how to play
There are six different tutorials in game to help new players learn the ins and outs of the game.
Cons
Con Developer has given up
Almost shut down 3 months ago, now the guy running the community is the only one doing anything
Con Few players
Very few play this game.
Con May feel pay to win
Collecting cards in the game can be difficult as no single card can be purchases, you can only get cards in packs that either cost real money or earned in game currency, which takes time and grinding to earn. This is exasperated by the fact that there is no secondary market where people can sell cards.
Con Old and outdated, no reason to play anymore
Con Game pushes players into purchasing cards
Progression in the game falls a bit flat, especially in the collecting aspect. This may be done in order to push people into paying for card packs instead of feeling like they steadily earn them through gameplay.