When comparing The Dark Mod vs Shadow Tactics: Blades of the Shogun, the Slant community recommends The Dark Mod for most people. In the question“What are the best stealth games for PC?” The Dark Mod is ranked 4th while Shadow Tactics: Blades of the Shogun is ranked 9th. The most important reason people chose The Dark Mod is:
The game is a community remake of the game Thief, not in terms of story, characters, or levels, but in terms of mechanics. Originally it was created as a mod for Doom 3, but has since been remade with original assets in order to have no liability, though it still uses the same mission. This means the game is free and will stay free. Players can download dozens of additional missions at no additional charge.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Free to all
The game is a community remake of the game Thief, not in terms of story, characters, or levels, but in terms of mechanics. Originally it was created as a mod for Doom 3, but has since been remade with original assets in order to have no liability, though it still uses the same mission. This means the game is free and will stay free. Players can download dozens of additional missions at no additional charge.
Pro Mentally stimulating stealth gameplay
This game pushes your problem-solving skills to the extreme, presenting stealth missions that almost feel like puzzles. You'll carefully navigate each level using one of the five infiltration specialists, creating distractions, cycling hiding spots, and assassinating enemy guards along the way. To make it even more interesting, the AI is quite intelligent, quickly reacting to anything you do without giving you any leeway. Because your actions have clearly defined reactions, it can be really fun to plan out your strategy for a level, so when your grand plan finally succeeds, it can feel incredibly satisfying.
Pro Spectacular visuals
Even though Shadow Tactics isn't a high budget game, the visuals look great, featuring excellent lighting, intricate shadow mapping, vivid water effects, detailed character models, and very polished, cel shaded textures. All of this helps bring the Edo period of Japanese history to life, allowing you to appreciate armor-clad Samurai and beautiful structures with curved roofs in their full splendor, which makes the experience a lot more enjoyable.
Pro Well-designed levels
There are 13 levels in total, each one having unique terrain, buildings, and enemy layouts. From rural settlements with run-down buildings, to imposing fortresses on cliffs and riverbanks. No two levels ever feel or play alike. Even though some of the more difficult levels can take up to 4 hours or more to complete initially, there's enough variety to keep it interesting from start to finish.
Cons
Con Oldish graphics
Although efforts are being done to keep it nice, The Dark Mod runs on an engine from 2004 and definitely looks dated compared to modern games.
Con Can be really frustrating
Shadow Tactics is a very difficult game, requiring a lot of trial and error to beat a level. This involves memorizing level layouts, enemy locations, and guard patrol routes. The game even goes as far as to remind you when you last saved, implying that it's really easy to mess up. A slight mistake can quickly result in failing a mission, which is extremely frustrating if you've been stuck at a section for some time, giving it a similar feeling to constantly banging your head on a wall.
Con Camera angles can sometimes get in the way of gameplay
ST: BotS is played from an isometric prespective, requiring you to rotate your camera quite often to get a proper overview of levels, especially because there's no transparency system. While this isn't a problem in slow sections of the game, the instant you have to make quick decisions, it becomes very easy to miss guards hiding behind carts, buildings, and even walls just because you didn't have the proper camera angle. Because of this, it sometimes might feel like you're not only fighting against the challenging AI, but also the game itself.