When comparing State of Decay: YOSE vs Oxygen Not Included, the Slant community recommends Oxygen Not Included for most people. In the question“What are the best Simulation games on Steam?” Oxygen Not Included is ranked 9th while State of Decay: YOSE is ranked 25th. The most important reason people chose Oxygen Not Included is:
For a light-hearted game, Oxygen Not Included takes laws of physics and biology very seriously. Characters, or Duplicants, require regular meals and fresh water. They can hold their breath, but only for a limited time. Extremely cold and hot temperatures hurt them. Given high enough stress level, they can even experience nervous breakdown that causes them to vomit excessively or start binge-eating colonie's food supplies.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro A variety of fun tasks are provided on top of the main storyline
There are many different tasks a player can take on such as fetch quests, rescue missions, or even just scoping a place out for the future. This gives the game a good bit of variety to the gameplay.
Pro Events that happen like the real world, whether you are logged in or not, creating a very realistic feeling game mechanic
There is an in game real-time-ish clock to the game, that even has events that happen when the player is not even logged in. Such as holidays or just events that mean something to the characters found within the game. This is not mirrored to the players real world time, but acts as its own time in the game.
Pro Bases can be compartmentally upgraded, giving a task to the player and something to strive for
Scavanged materials can be used to upgrade parts of the players base such as infirmaries or sleeping quarters. This gives the player something to strive for, searching out new materials in order to upgrade on more section of their home base.
Pro Realistic game mechanics
For a light-hearted game, Oxygen Not Included takes laws of physics and biology very seriously. Characters, or Duplicants, require regular meals and fresh water. They can hold their breath, but only for a limited time. Extremely cold and hot temperatures hurt them. Given high enough stress level, they can even experience nervous breakdown that causes them to vomit excessively or start binge-eating colonie's food supplies.
Pro Loveable, cute characters
Every Duplicant has a name and unique appearance, as well as personal traits. They are very cute and funny, which makes you fully invested in their well-being.
Pro Requires advanced planning
This game provides a real challenge when it comes to planning your base's inner layout. You need to take into account gas and fluid dynamics to ensure that your Duplicants have breathable air and aren't intoxicated by contaminated water.
Cons
Con Poor collision detection
Combat is not the best, poor collision detection means more button mashing than skill is needed.
Con Maps are limited in size, causing you to eventually lose
Since the map size is limited, so is the supply of resources, meaning that sooner or later you invariably loose the game.