When comparing The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition vs Grim Fandango Remastered, the Slant community recommends The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition for most people. In the question“What are the best point and click adventure games on PC?” The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition is ranked 3rd while Grim Fandango Remastered is ranked 7th. The most important reason people chose The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition is:
This remastered edition offers new graphics as well as all new voice acting for the whole of the game. There is also on offer a retro graphical version, for those that would like to experience the original. This way new and old players alike can play as they wish to experience the title.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Retro and newly redone version of the game
This remastered edition offers new graphics as well as all new voice acting for the whole of the game. There is also on offer a retro graphical version, for those that would like to experience the original. This way new and old players alike can play as they wish to experience the title.
Pro fun / smart a must try adventure !
Pro Inspired by the day of the Dead holiday, Mexican folklore and film Noire
Grim Fandango is self admittedly inspired by the Day of the Dead Mexican holiday as well as Noir style films.
Pro Challenging
Compared to modern point and click Grim Fandango actually requires the player to pay closer attention to details or even take their own notes. While this may not be everyones cup of tea, for long time point and click adventure game players it is a refreshing change back to the norm.
Pro A world of depth
The world is immersive and the characters feel like real people.
Pro Stellar writing and voice acting
While the art design and music come together to create a cohesive world oozing with atmosphere, the near-Pixar quality voice work and writing breath life into the characters in way few other games have managed to achieve.
Pro Improved controls and UI
The controls were remastered to feel like more modern point and click adventure games I instead of the tank controls that turned so long time gamers off. From fully enjoying the game. The UI was cleaned up and made easier to use
Pro New commentary track
The current remastered developers have added a new commentary track from the original key developers to the game.
Cons
Con Worse than the original
The original had better graphics (pixel-art), which contributed to the overall allure of the game.
Con Difficult to differentiate interactive objects from background
As a point and click adventure game, there will be objects one needs to interact with or collect in each stage. Where trouble sets in is that some of these objects can be difficult to see as they blend in with the stage itself. While this does offer a hidden object aspects, it sometimes leads to being stuck as the object needed to progress is so hidden that the player just can not find it.
Con Improved controls and interface
The controls were remastered to feel like more modern point and click adventure games I instead of the tank controls that turned so long time gamers off. From fully enjoying the game. The UI was cleaned up and made easier to use
Con Some puzzles are obtuse
While the quality of puzzles is generally fantastic, there are a few offenders that may force players to resort to a "hail Mary" strategy of clicking anything and everything in hopes of stumbling on the solution.
Con No tutorial
A missed opportunity with this remake is the chance to finally add a tutorial.