When comparing Muffin Knight vs Reaper, the Slant community recommends Reaper for most people. In the question“What are the best Android games with MOGA controller support?” Reaper is ranked 13th while Muffin Knight is ranked 16th. The most important reason people chose Reaper is:
Mobile games are great for playing for just a new minutes here and there, and Reaper works exactly like that. If you've only got 5 minutes, you can still enjoy it. Some mobile RPGs need plenty of time to get into the mood and enjoy, which isn't always possible on mobile.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Co-op multiplayer works seamlessly across systems
There is cross platform (iOS,Android) co-op multiplayer available to all players, which works great and is easy to use, even when playing against someone on a different OS.
Pro 2 player local co-op that encourages teamwork
In 2 player co-op, each player has their own specific muffins they need to collect. These spawn in two at a time - one for each player. However, both players must get their muffin before new ones will appear. This means even after you collect your muffin, you'll have to help your teammate get theirs no matter what. It's a neat little mechanic that has you and a friend working together to navigate the map and kill enemies.
Pro Interesting shapeshifting mechanic keeps gameplay fresh
Every time you collect a muffin when going through the various levels, your character transforms into a random creature. While every form can jump and run, each one has different abilities which will change up the gameplay. There's a frog who can attack from long range his tongue, a unicorn who uses rainbow bombs, an archer who shoots arrows, and many more. You never know what form you'll take when collecting a muffin, and since there's so many muffins to collect, you'll constantly be swapping forms and trying new things throughout the entire game. It's a neat mechanic that really keeps things from getting stale, and trying out all the different forms is both interesting and fun.
Pro Stylish 3D graphics give a pleasant cartoony look
The graphics are presented in a 2D environment but are rendered in 3D, all with vibrant colors and detailing that makes the whole game look cartoony. It's a cheery and bright aesthetic that is pleasant to look at and play.
Pro Great controls allow the game to be easily controlled on a touchscreen
For what can make or break every platformer in existence, Muffin Knight luckily has great controls for a mobile title. They are very responsive and running/jumping around each level is an overall smooth experience.
Pro MOGA controller and Bluetooth keybinding support
Moga and Moga Pro controllers are supported. Additionally, you can use a bluetooth keyboard to map the controls if you prefer to play with a keyboard.
Pro Playable in small chunks
Mobile games are great for playing for just a new minutes here and there, and Reaper works exactly like that. If you've only got 5 minutes, you can still enjoy it. Some mobile RPGs need plenty of time to get into the mood and enjoy, which isn't always possible on mobile.
Pro Full game content unlock in app purchase
There are three in app purchases with the last one being a full game content unlock at $4.99.
Pro Controller support
Reaper supports HID game controllers including MOGA, Nvidea and NYKO.
Pro Colorful backgrounds and character models
The graphics exude a lot of personality and attention to detail.
Pro Great touch screen controls
There are two options for touch screen controls, one being swipe based and the other being directional buttons.
Cons
Con Contains in app purchases even though the game costs money already
Even though the game is already a paid title, there are additional, optional in-app purchases that can be used to make the game easier.
Con Doesn't have much longevity
The entire game is based around combat, which works in small doses. For longer playtimes though, it can get pretty repetitive. That goes for the extra content unlocked through the in-app purchase as well - it's more of the same in new levels.
Con Free gameplay is limited to ten levels
The gameplay is free up to the tenth level, at that point an in app purchase has to be made of which there are three depending on how much content you want. $3 unlocks the rest of the levels, while $4 nets you more in-game items, and $5 gets you everything available as well as the Dark Harvest game mode.