When comparing Promoter vs Vlambeer Toolkit, the Slant community recommends Vlambeer Toolkit for most people. In the question“What are the best press management tools for independent games?” Vlambeer Toolkit is ranked 1st while Promoter is ranked 2nd. The most important reason people chose Vlambeer Toolkit is:
Each tool is presented as a turnkey solution to a common task which is either time-consuming or easily mishandled without experience.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Promo code tracking and assignment
Promotional codes for e.g. Steam can be loaded into Promoter, and then assigned to press contacts either directly or through a request form (with approval). Assigned codes will be associated with later coverage.
Pro Press contact management and analytics
In addition to providing a curated list of press contacts, Promoter tracks who you've actually contacted, and which of those contacts result in coverage.
Pro Automated aggregation for press and YouTube exposure
Promoter's core feature is a self-updating timeline view of press mentions from an enormous list of sources, including YouTube. Awards and review scores are also tracked.
Pro Streamlined single-purpose tools are fast and easy to use
Each tool is presented as a turnkey solution to a common task which is either time-consuming or easily mishandled without experience.
Pro Includes a list other recommended resources
In addition to Rami's own tools, the toolkit page links to tools by others with the same "do one job and do it well" design. There are also several links to informational resources which Rami considers essential material for new developers.
Cons
Con Some tools require private hosting
Many of Rami's tools are implemented in PHP and expect to be accessed from a dedicated web server (i.e. you host your own copy). If you don't already have a website with full server access, they may lack the convenience of hosted services. However, they can be run from a free localhost server; so paying for a host is not required.