When comparing MSDN XNA Walkthrough vs Unity Scripting Tutorials, the Slant community recommends Unity Scripting Tutorials for most people. In the question“What are the best game programming tutorials for beginners?” Unity Scripting Tutorials is ranked 3rd while MSDN XNA Walkthrough is ranked 6th. The most important reason people chose Unity Scripting Tutorials is:
Unity's tutorials use C# as the default language, a skill which is directly useful elsewhere.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Starts at the very beginning
Takes through the whole process of creating a game from scratch using XNA.
Pro Covers multiple XNA versions
Tutorial available for XNA 4.0 as well as 3.1.
Pro Teaches C#
Unity's tutorials use C# as the default language, a skill which is directly useful elsewhere.
Pro Video tutorials
Unity's entire tutorial series is presented in video format, with associated source code provided in text. For many, this is an easier way to learn than text and screenshots.
Cons
Con Video tutorials
Unity's entire tutorial series is presented in video format. For some, this is is a harder way to learn than text and screenshots.
Con Scripting tutorials assume general knowledge of Unity3D
Scripting is not the first topic presented in the Unity tutorial series, and it is assumed that you are already familiar with Unity's basic operation. For those who are just starting out, this could mean some extra study before getting into programming.