When comparing JavaScript: The Good Parts vs The Odin Project, the Slant community recommends The Odin Project for most people. In the question“What are the best resources to learn JavaScript?” The Odin Project is ranked 5th while JavaScript: The Good Parts is ranked 6th. The most important reason people chose The Odin Project is:
The Odin Project is a project-based curriculum which means you are able to build projects for your portfolio as you work through the sections.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Explains what makes JS confusing and how to go about it
JS can be a confusing language and often provides difficulty writing good code that uses objects and methods. Crockford explains why that is and how to think about the language to avoid confusion.
Pro Good for intermediate programmers
The book requires basic understating of how programming works and even some understanding of JavaScript itself.
Pro Build a portfolio as your learn
The Odin Project is a project-based curriculum which means you are able to build projects for your portfolio as you work through the sections.
Pro Free and open source
The Odin Project is a completely free and open source alternative to coding bootcamps.
Cons
Con Lack of consistency
Where some parts of the book cover very basic concepts, other parts expect at least an intermediate understanding on JavaScript. There is a lack of consistency, causing some confusion as to who the book is aimed at.
Con Light on CS
The Odin Project touches on computer science concepts, such as data structures. However the explanations are quite light and something you'll want to learn more about from other resources.