When comparing Star Realms vs Magic 2015, the Slant community recommends Star Realms for most people. In the question“What are the best card battle games on Android similar to Hearthstone?” Star Realms is ranked 4th while Magic 2015 is ranked 13th. The most important reason people chose Star Realms is:
Asynchronous online play allows for the player to get matched up against a friend or random opponent.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Asynchronous online play
Asynchronous online play allows for the player to get matched up against a friend or random opponent.
Pro Bases
Bases are permanent cards on the playing field that each player needs to try and destroy but giving that there is a choice each turn to hit a base or the players ships, it becomes a juggling act of what takes priority to destroy.
Pro Unpredictable
There is no way for the player to know what will be in their hand or what they will eventually be able to purchase, making for every game being unpredictable.
Pro Pass and play multiplayer on a single device
Players can play a multiplayer game locally using a single device by passing the device between the two players for each ones turn. This makes for an easy way to duel when only one device is around.
Pro Single player mode
There is an included single player mode where the player faces off against the CPU.
Pro Six tutorials to help players learn how to play
There are six different tutorials in game to help new players learn the ins and outs of the game.
Pro Deep gaming experience
The core of the Magic games is extremely deep with years of additions, tweaks and new rules to broaden the scope of the whole game.
Cons
Con Design is lacking
More thought, design and production value could have been added to the game to give it a better polished feel, sadly it is not the case as most aspects pass as just serviceable.
Con Old and outdated, no reason to play anymore
Con Game pushes players into purchasing cards
Progression in the game falls a bit flat, especially in the collecting aspect. This may be done in order to push people into paying for card packs instead of feeling like they steadily earn them through gameplay.