When comparing Qingy vs GDM, the Slant community recommends GDM for most people. In the question“What is the best Linux Display Manager?” GDM is ranked 8th while Qingy is ranked 16th. The most important reason people chose GDM is:
GDM is dull, but it just works, and it is highly stable. It's easy to switch between environments, and it integrates really well with Fedora or other Gnome Distros.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Getty replacement
It is a getty replacement so it will not only replace your X11 login manager but also your getty.
Pro It just works
GDM is dull, but it just works, and it is highly stable. It's easy to switch between environments, and it integrates really well with Fedora or other Gnome Distros.
Pro Can run Wayland sessions
GDM can start Wayland sessions, which is the default for recent GNOME versions.
Pro Always signs the GNOME keyring
Works with any desktop. SOome display managers such as SDDM don't open the GNOME keyring at login.
Pro Not so difficult to customize
You just have to know which files to edit, and you can do quite a lot.
Cons
Con Ancient fossil dredged up from nearly a decade ago
Qingy doesn't appear to have updated since 2010. That's a long time in Internet years.
Con Not a display manager
Qingy is not a display manager - it is a getty replacement.
Con Tied to Gnome
You basically have to use Gnome or one of its forks to use it properly.
Con Really hard to customize
You'll have to recompile Gnome's resource files in order just to change the login background.
Con Depends on GTK and its dependencies
Con Ugly UI
It is very simple, and you can't change the layout.
Con Bloated
As with anything Gnome, there's a level of inelegance to be expected when it comes to absolute performance. It's supposed to be a login manager, not something bespoke.