When comparing iMpulse controller vs Sminiker Gamepad, the Slant community recommends Sminiker Gamepad for most people. In the question“What are the best third-party game controllers for Android?” Sminiker Gamepad is ranked 11th while iMpulse controller is ranked 16th. The most important reason people chose Sminiker Gamepad is:
There is a detachable phone holder which can be mounted to the controller. When on the go, it can be hard to find a place to prop your phone up, which makes a phone holder like this very useful.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Works great with emulators
The iMpulse works great with emulators in that the controls can be programmed from within the emulator application, thus creating no need for the iMpulse application.
Pro First party apps
There are three different apps for use on the iMpulse that add functionality to the device such as button mapping or a key finder.
Pro Rechargable battery
The iMpulse controller uses an in built rechargable battery that is charged through a USB port.
Pro Holds your phone for you
There is a detachable phone holder which can be mounted to the controller. When on the go, it can be hard to find a place to prop your phone up, which makes a phone holder like this very useful.
Pro Comfortable for long gaming sessions
The controller is full sized, which means that your hands aren't cramped trying to hold onto a miniature controller.
Pro Stores 4 device's info for easy switching
The Sminiker Gamepad can hold onto 4 device's pairing status and switch between them with the click of a button. Most controllers need to be un-paired, and then re-paired each time you switch devices. This helps make the Gamepad more attractive if you have both a phone and a tablet, or wish to share your controller with your kids/friends, or anyone else.
Cons
Con No analog sticks
Without the inclusion of analog sticks playing 3D games may be troublesome.
Con Apps do not work that great
There does seem to be a multitude of problems with the first party apps available for this device including a horrible UI and non working functions.
Con Only works with Android
Many of the other controllers can work with either Windows, iOS, or both...however the Sminiker Gamepad only works with Android phones.
Con Cheap components
The build quality of the Sminiker isn't great, and the included charging USB cable is short and can break easily based on numerous reviews.