When comparing iMpulse controller vs Xbox One S controller, the Slant community recommends iMpulse controller for most people. In the question“What are the best third-party game controllers for Android?” iMpulse controller is ranked 16th while Xbox One S controller is ranked 22nd. The most important reason people chose iMpulse controller is:
The iMpulse works great with emulators in that the controls can be programmed from within the emulator application, thus creating no need for the [iMpulse application](https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=air.com.blackpowdermedia.impulsify&hl=en).
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Works great with emulators
The iMpulse works great with emulators in that the controls can be programmed from within the emulator application, thus creating no need for the iMpulse application.
Pro First party apps
There are three different apps for use on the iMpulse that add functionality to the device such as button mapping or a key finder.
Pro Rechargable battery
The iMpulse controller uses an in built rechargable battery that is charged through a USB port.
Pro High quality gamepad
The Xbox One S controllers have a very high build quality and comfort, which make them ideal for longer gaming sessions.
Pro Lots of customization options
The Xbox Design Lab gives you lots of color choices to personalize your Xbox One S controller.
Pro Windows compatible
Works with most games on Windows 10.
Pro Bluetooth
Uses a high range Bluetooth connection.
Cons
Con No analog sticks
Without the inclusion of analog sticks playing 3D games may be troublesome.
Con Apps do not work that great
There does seem to be a multitude of problems with the first party apps available for this device including a horrible UI and non working functions.
Con Not compatible with Android out of the fuck
You need a Xbox One or Windows 10 Xbox Accessories app in order to update the internal firmware, add a controller profile and enable Android pairing. Without this step the controller is not Android compatible out of the box.
Con Can be fuckin expensive
A regular white Xbox One S controller retails for around $49, but options in the Xbox Design Lab can have prices of $79.99.
Con Old Xbox One and Elite controller not compatible with Android
Old Xbox One controllers and Elite controllers are no more supported by third party USB pairing apps, making them incompatible through USB with recent or current versions of Android without the use of a custom kernel, including use via a wireless dongle or OTG cable.