When comparing 13th Age vs Monsters & Magic, the Slant community recommends 13th Age for most people. In the question“What are the best tabletop RPGs?” 13th Age is ranked 27th while Monsters & Magic is ranked 42nd. The most important reason people chose 13th Age is:
The world is half built, letting you get in and leave your mark. Each class plays mechanically different than other d20 versions. Skills are placed by backgrounds. It's a short hand and interesting way of playing DnD.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro The game is built for people who've done it before
The world is half built, letting you get in and leave your mark. Each class plays mechanically different than other d20 versions. Skills are placed by backgrounds. It's a short hand and interesting way of playing DnD.
Pro Long lists of skills are gone completely
And covered by backgrounds (much like FATE or Cortex+) so that players aren't searching through lists of skills and what they can do constantly.
Pro Gonzo without the grid
13th Age has some very gonzo fights with party combos, lots of variable powers for monsters and PC's but as a simple set of rules for combat that speed it up without losing a lot of options.
Pro The Effect Engine
The game uses a single core mechanic, which is flexible enough to cover a wide variety of situations. This helps GMs immensely when characters want to do things that aren't already covered in the system.
The mechanic itself works thusly: all rolls are 3d6 + modifiers minus difficulty. The result is how many effect points the player can apply to the action -- or, if negative, how many consequence points their opponent can apply to a reaction. Dealing damage is one use of effect points, but there's a limit on how much can be dealt at once, so additional effects (e.g. distracting, disarming, unmounting, etc.) see constant play instead of only being used rarely or by super-specialists. This also means failure is interesting, since it results in consequences!
This mechanic is used to do everything, and the game essentially consists of nothing but examples of how to use it.
Pro Interesting combat
Attacks generate effect points, which you spend to do things to your opponent. However, the amount of damage you can do is limited, which forces players to do other things... and the effect system is broad enough that these can be things like cutting off a carrion crawler's tentacles, knocking an opponent's sword out of their hand, and so on. Failures on attack generate consequence points as well, which your opponent can use to do things to you.
Pro Mental defense and hit points
Characters have a "Mental Defense" score and "Mental Hit Points". These are used to help provide a unified system for handling social encounters and mental attacks via magic.
Cons
Con Too similar to 4th
Con The Icons and the PC relationships to them can confuse
Can be confusing, especially for new players.
Con It doesn't really do anything new, it just looks pretty
Con Not currently available in print
Is only available in PDF.
Con Few monsters & spells provided
The included rules have only about 20 monsters and 1st and 2nd-level spells. Third party publishers have supplements that provide more, or you can use ones from old D&D.