When comparing FreeCommander vs Altap Salamander, the Slant community recommends Altap Salamander for most people. In the question“What are the best file managers for Windows?” Altap Salamander is ranked 8th while FreeCommander is ranked 12th.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pro 2 Pane Layout
Makes normal file operations (like move & copy) easy.
Pro Has a portable version
Because it's portable, you can easily move the folder with all your files to other devices.
Pro Keyboard shortcuts
Has a good set of keyboard shortcuts enabled by default
Pro Very powerful set of file copying options
FreeCommander has a very powerful set of file copying options.
Pro Powerful search feature
FreeCommander provides a search functionality that allows you to filter out results.
Pro Very stable, even preview versions
Pro License is good on multiple machines
Can be used at home and work.
Pro Very feature-rich
Pro Looks very polished and consistent
Pro Intuitive two-pane interface
The program features a dual-pane interface that allows you to easily move files between views.
Pro Powerful bookmark support
Easy bookmark usage, e.g., Shift+1 selects the first directory. The bookmarked directories are also available in the usual popups to switch the left/right drive (Alt+F1/F2).
Pro Built-in FTP and SFTP
The program has built in support for a variety of common network protocols (such as FTP, FTPS, SCP and SFTP) for file transferring over the internet.
Pro Customizable with own external tools
Pro Customizable colors
Different colors can be assigned to compressed files or files with a certain name pattern.
Pro Very fast
No delay is noticable in the user interface.
Pro Extensive keyboard shortcut support
Pro Built-in undelete plugin
Pro Built-in archive support (zip, rar, etc)
Pro Automation plugin
Enables user to automate repetitious actions via JScript and VBScript (via windows script engines already installed). There is also support for Perl, PHP, Python and Ruby (Arton's ruby must be installed to have the Action script support)
Pro Copy and move operations can work in background
Con Only the 32-bit version is free
You have to make a donation to be able to download the 64-bit version.
Good facilities overall, but there's a bug that makes menus freeze and get stuck on the page.
Con It's easy to delete important stuff by accident
When you want to delete something, it will often highlight both a file and its folder. The whole folder is then removed if you don't de-select the folder manually.
Con Cluttered and dated UI
The user interface has an outdated look, with a lot of button and menu options that can be overwhelming.
Con No Unicode support
Unicode was promised many years ago, but due to slow development, still nothing.
Con Text Viewer does not support UTF-8
Con Slow development
Con Winscp not available for x64 version
Winscp plugin is available only for x86 version and missing @x64.
Con Is only available for Windows
There is no full replacement for Linux or OS X.
Con Hard-coded shortcuts
Shortcuts are hard-coded and therefore can't be changed by the user.
Con No tabs in dual panes
There are no tabs available in the dual panes view, which can be a time-saver for some users.