Add to Chrome
Add to Edge
Add to Firefox
Add to Opera
Add to Brave
Add to SafariHypothesis vs Lumio
When comparing Hypothesis vs Lumio, the Slant community recommends Hypothesis for most people. In the question“What are the best browser research plugin or extension for bookmarking and note taking?” Hypothesis is ranked 3rd while Lumio is ranked 9th. The most important reason people chose Hypothesis is:
Hypothesis is completely free and open source, its source code is hosted in GitHub.
Question Ranking
Pros
Pro Open Source
Hypothesis is completely free and open source, its source code is hosted in GitHub.
Pro Everything can be searched through
Searchable stream of annotations, replies, and email notifications.
Pro Private or public
You can work in private groups and then publish, keep annotations private, or make it public from scratch.
Pro Tags
You can sort by tags, which makes it far more powerful.
Pro Lets you see public & private annotations on that webpage
Helpful to see what people thought or see useful references they might have left. Useful for group collaborations as well (research groups, book clubs, class study groups, etc)
Pro Chrome browser extension works on Brave browser
Most (maybe all) Chromium-based browsers let you use Chrome browser extensions.
Pro Chrome browser extension
Has browser extension for Chrome, which makes the job of annotating web pages even easier.
Pro Unique URLs for each annotation
You can link directly to an annotation.
Pro Organise marks & clippings
Organize your highlights in collections the way you organize songs in playlists. Drag and drop to re-arrange them in the order you like.
Pro Offline access
Read and organize all your saved stuff offline.
Pro Clip/Mark anything
Select and clip text, data, posts, tweets, images, and videos, even PDF documents.
Cons
Con No browser extensions apart from Chrome
Allegedly, one can use bookmarklet instead, but in Firefox it works only for some of websites.
Con Seems under development
Too many rough edges and/or bugs as you use it. For example, you have to keep logging in every time you want to add a page using the chrome extension. There are ways to add annotations on the mobile too, but way too buggy. Hopefully they fix these problems soon. Very good idea; poorly implemented.
Con Annotations are for text only, not images
Con Terminated its service in November 2018.
Farewell.
