Here’s the Deal

Nightwatch.js vs Endtest

31 3

41 13

When comparing Nightwatch.js vs Endtest, the Slant community recommends Nightwatch.js for most people. In the question“What are the best Javascript end-to-end testing tools?” Nightwatch.js is ranked 2nd while Endtest is ranked 9th. The most important reason people chose Nightwatch.js is:

Nightwatch solves the [Paradox of Choice](http://www.ted.com/talks/barry_schwartz_on_the_paradox_of_choice?language=en) among testing frameworks such as Jasmine, Cucumber or Mocha+Chai, by including its own BDD-style assertion library, based on Chai.

Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking

Common Questions

What are the best Javascript end-to-end testing tools?

Pros

Pro
You don't have to choose a testing framework

Nightwatch solves the Paradox of Choice among testing frameworks such as Jasmine, Cucumber or Mocha+Chai, by including its own BDD-style assertion library, based on Chai.

Pro
Includes its own testing framework / assertions library

Pro
Test organization is out of the box

Supports page object model, custom commands, custom assertions, and globals.js.

Pro
3rd party integration with Cucumber

Though Cucumber is not officially supported, Nightwatch can be used with Cucumber.

Pro
Codeless automated testing

Endtest allows you to create automated tests for web applications, directly on their cloud infrastructure. No coding skills are required.
You can also choose the action "Execute Javascript" for a more flexible test run.

Pro
Running your automated tests on their cloud infrastructure

You can easily run your automated tests on their platform, just by clicking the run button.

Pro
Designed for Continuous Integration

It has an API which allows testers to run it on Jenkins or Team City. Other than that, it has a built-in test scheduler to allow testers to preset test executions.

Pro
Now supports mobile testing

Endtest has added a new feature which now supports mobile testing for both Android and iOS (.apk and .ipa).

Pro
Option to export your automated tests in different formats, including .EXE

You can export your automated tests in a variety of different formats, and run them on your own infrastructure. The formats are either in Python file format or executable file format (.EXE).

Pro
Now supports a wider variety of browsers, operating system and devices

As of March 2018, Endtest can now support multiple platforms (Windows, MAC, Android and iOS), Operating Systems, and more than a handful of devices for both Android and iOS.

Pro
Super fast and affordable.

Pro
Premium version is relatively cheaper than most in the market

Their pricing plan ($79/month or $650/year) includes team plan upgrade, which means the whole team, regardless of the number of users, will only need to subscribe to the $79/month or $650/year plan. This includes unlimited test runs, test exports, recordings, etc.

Pro
It's mostly free to use

The free plan covers a lot, you can have up to 3 test suites, and you can run your automated tests as many times as you want. The pro plan includes some very advanced options that you might need only if you're working with a team (for example, the collaboration feature, schedule test run, API for Jenkins, etc.).

Ad
Cons

Con
No official BDD-style syntax support

Con
Includes its own testing framework / assertions library

Unlike WebdriverIO, which lets you use various test frameworks and assertion libraries (e.g. Jasmine, Cucumber, Mocha + Chai), Nightwatch comes with its own BDD-style interface for performing assertions, based on Chai.

Here's a simple test example:

module.exports = {
  'Demo test Google' : function (browser) {
    browser
      .url('http://www.google.com')
      .waitForElementVisible('body', 1000)
      .setValue('input[type=text]', 'nightwatch')
      .waitForElementVisible('button[name=btnG]', 1000)
      .click('button[name=btnG]')
      .pause(1000)
      .assert.containsText('#main', 'Night Watch')
      .end();
  }
};

Con
Doesn't support a wide array of browsers and/or operating systems

Because it's still in its infancy, it doesn't yet have a huge variety of browsers and operating systems.

Con
Free plan has limited time storage for test suites

If you are using the free plan, keep in mind that the test suites created there are scheduled to be deleted after around 2 weeks. Endtest will send you a notification email the day before mentioning "Test suites from users who are not on the PRO Plan get automatically deleted after some time," and offering for you to upgrade to PRO.