What is the best mobile operating system?

Question

12

Options
Considered

512

User
Recs.

Sep 30, 2019

Last
Updated

Here’s the Deal

5 Options Considered

Best mobile operating system	Price	OS Family	License
89 Android	-	Linux (AOSP-based)	mostly Apache 2.0
88 Sailfish OS	-	Linux	-
62 iOS	-	UNIX (BSD-based)	-
-- Tizen	-	Linux	-
-- KaiOS	-	Linux	-

See Full List

I Recommend...

Help millions of people make better decisions.

Each month, over 2.8 million people use Slant to find the best products and share their knowledge. Pick the tags you’re passionate about to get a personalized feed and begin contributing your knowledge.

score 135 · Answer 1

Android

Top Pro

Customize what apps perform what actions

Android gives users the ability to define which apps perform which action. For example, if an Android device has several browsers installed, the user can choose a default one which will start every time a link is for example opened from another app. See More

Top Con

Fragmentation and security flaws due to negligence.

Most Android phones seem to be released on a "Let's release a few software updates until we release the next phone, and never push out an update again." For example, In May 2014, 8.5% of phones were Kitkat, 60.8% were spread out between three versions of jellybean (with bias towards older versions), and the another 20% spread out over ICS, Honeycomb, Gingerbread, and Froyo. Google no longer maintains Android 4.3 or prior and serious security exploits remain in those versions. Device manufacturers are also taking no action, which leaves almost a billion Android users exposed. You may also encounter lingering and unfixed bugs, glitches, etc. as a result of the manufacturer's and Google's lack of interest in older versions. Some flagship phones are well supported into the future, but the fact that your phone won't be supported by its manufacturer and/or Google is a consideration you must make when purchasing an Android phone. See More

Infernal Apex's Experience

Flexible, customizable, side-loadable and fast. Root and repurpose out of contact phones and older tablets for always-on IoT devices - home security cameras, motion sensors, cloud music player, Netflix remote, crypto mining, etc.. See More

Specs

OS Family:Linux (AOSP-based)

License:mostly Apache 2.0

Top Pro

Open source

The AOSP (Android Open Source Project) is the software stack for the Android OS. It is led by Google. The fact that Android is an open source software has led to many custom Android variants. It also is a big assurance of Android's safety in terms of privacy. See More

Top Con

Wide variety of phones forces variance in quality

While there are many great Android phones, there are also many Android phones that lack in both hardware and software. When purchasing Android phones, a consumer might want to do some research first - especially when buying on a budget. Not only do you have to worry about shotty hardware or poor quality testing, manufacturers tend to tinker with the software on phones. More often than not this leads to poor performance, unintuitive 'features', slower (or complete lack of) updates, and custom software that detracts from the user's experience. See More

Capuccino 's Experience

Android emphasizes the philosophy of "Be together, not the same". The OS itself promotes a more robust diversity and consumer choice, which makes it a succesful product as a Phone OS See More

Top Pro

Lots of hardware choices

There are about 18000 released devices that run on Android. This means that a user familiar with Android can have a large variety of devices from which they can choose. See More

Top Con

Difficult to use for pro audio

Android M paired with newer devices are getting audio latency down to 20 milliseconds or less, which is great compared to previous Android versions, however is still slower than Apple's 7ms on the iPhone 4S - a 4 year old phone. There are almost no professional audio tools available for Android because the latency was way too slow for professional audio creation, but perhaps now that Android isn't so far back we will start to see a few options come to Android. See More

SophisticatedMidir's Experience

It's far better than iOS now. Ease of access and great security See More

Top Pro

Integration with Google Services

For those that already use Google's services, like Google Maps and GMail, Android offers tighter integration with those services than any of the alternatives, and saves users the need to create extra accounts. See More

Top Con

App permission issues

Any users from Android M onward are not affected by this issue. Permissions are only granted via a pop-up when the app requests. The application permission system used requires requesting access to more user data than should be needed to run an app. For example, in order to enable matchmaking in games the app needs access to contacts list. Additionally, since Google doesn't enforce requesting only the permissions necessary for an app to function, a culture of requesting permissions that aren't in any way needed for the app to function has emerged. See More

HumbleKingu's Experience

Highly customizable and has a lot of support for apps See More

Top Pro

Highly customizable

One of the massive benefits of Android being open-sourced are all the modifications you can make to the phone to customise pretty much anything. Some of the cooler things you can do are: Replace the entire operating system with a custom ROM. Replace the keyboard. Change the home screen launcher. Change the lock screen. See More

Electric Games's Experience

Horrible. Just horrible. See More

Top Pro

More integrated sharing options

CreativeBanebdjedet's Experience

I have Android 7.0 what's the top Android is 2018 See More

Top Pro

Desktop and lockscreen widgets

Desktop widgets provide quick access to the information you need quickly and access the most. These are available out of the box, and can be developed by anyone. Widgets on the lockscreen have been removed since the Lollipop update, but is available on 3rd party lockscreens such as AC Display and KK Locker. See More

Top Pro

Accessibility

Built in text to speech is provided by TalkBack for people with low or no vision. Enhancements for people with hearing disabilities are available as are other aids. See More

Top Pro

Personal assistant with Google Now

Google Now is an intelligent personal assistant available within the Google Search mobile application for the Android and iOS operating systems. It's software that makes your life more convenient by giving you all the information you need at any moment. See More

Top Pro

Great user experience right out of the box

Top Pro

The most widely used mobile OS

Top Pro

Consistent back button makes navigation easy

Top Pro

Built-in screen recording

Android 5.0.+ supports screen recording via a new api. Android 4.4 KitKat supports screen recording accessible via an ADB command on unrooted devices. See More

Top Pro

Cheap phones

Android phones can cost little as $100. See More

Top Pro

Customizable multiple "desktops"

Can customize the home screens with widgets (not just a grid of apps like iOS). See More

Top Pro

Security Updates

Android does frequent updates to keep users secure See More

Top Pro

It's all yours. You can do anything you want with YOUR phone...

See All

score 37 · Answer 2

Sailfish OS

Top Pro

Unique gesture-based interface

There are no buttons needed to use it. See More

Top Con

Only a few native apps, needs Android support to access many apps

Users may need to install Google Play store or other alternative android app store to access your bank's app or any highly specific app you might need. See More

PhilosophicalAinina's Experience

Best OS ever See More

Specs

OS Family:Linux

Top Pro

Lower power consumptions

Top Con

Only a few available phones

There are currently only a few available phones on the market with Sailfish OS and both the Jolla and the Jolla Tablet are out of stock and unavailable. See More

PoliteOrcus's Experience

usability + privacy See More

Top Pro

No annoying search bar that you might not be able to remove

You can actually manage your files. The third option to iOS vs Android. See More

Top Pro

Inbuilt Terminal app and ssh essentials

Smartphone for power users, not just for users. See More

Top Pro

Easy to use Swipe UI

Tutorials. See More

Top Pro

No pre-installed Google services

But if you want, you can install it. See More

Top Pro

Usability and privacy

No private data transfer to other companies. See More

Top Pro

Very customizable

You can use patches to change UI or other stuff. See More

Top Pro

Nearly monthly updates and security fixes

Version history. See More

See All

score 84 · Answer 3

iOS

Top Pro

Great selection of high quality and polished apps

Apps must pass tighter guidelines to make it into the app store. See More

Top Con

No file managing

Managing files and directories is not possible. Files are in fact attached to applications. It is an oversimplification that can be limiting. See More

Electrux Redsworth's Experience

A bit limiting, yes, but rock stable, and smooth which easily makes it worthwhile to use :) See More

Specs

OS Family:UNIX (BSD-based)

Update frequency:Common for new models, very little for older ones

Compatible devices:iPhone and iPod Touch, iPad

Top Pro

Everything works very well out of the box

It's engineered to be designed. Design means choice. A collection of best options, components and programs chosen by highly experienced curators/designers/engineers are installed by default. No need to customize. It's best by default. See More

Top Con

Not very customisable

Other operating systems like Android or Windows Phone (more or less), iOS isn't as customizable. See More

NonchalantAlecto's Experience

EASY See More

Top Pro

Consistent performance

Unlike Android, iOS is developed to be used on similiar devices and both the hardware and iOS itself are developed by Apple. This means that they are highly adapted to work with each other. Even after the hardware becomes a little outdated, the performance still remains consistent and smooth on several iOS versions. See More

Top Con

Inconveninet price and hardware lock-in

iOS is only available on iPhone, iPad and iPod Touch, in which these device may be more expensive than the competitors. See More

Buster Blue's Experience

It's too limiting and closed off. See More

Top Pro

Easy to learn to use

The iOS user interface is known by millions. It has mostly stayed the same throughout the years. The main view is a simple grid menu which displays all the installed applications. On the bottom there is an app tray which displays the icons for the most used apps. The iOS user interface is especially easy for users who want an easy experience and don't want to spend time learning on how to navigate through their phones. Everything is displayed right in the main view and it's easy to find. The fact that it has not changed, at least significantly in the past years has made it possible for it's most devoted users to keep upgrading their iOS devices without having any difficulty to adapt. See More

Top Con

Tied to Apple

No alternative software can be installed unless you keep your phone jailbroken (with the system outdated and probably with security issues). See More

Electric Games's Experience

AMAZING See More

Top Pro

Personal assistant called Siri

Siri is an intelligent personal assistant and knowledge navigator. Siri lets you use your voice to send messages, schedule meetings, place phone calls, and more. See More

Top Con

Older iPhone models with poorer batteries might perform slower

iOS delibrately slows the CPU down on older iPhones with worn-out batteries so as to preserve battery life, resulting in possible slower-than-expected performance. This only applies to iPhone 6, iPhone 6S, and iPhone SE running iOS 10.2.1 and above, and iPhone 7 running iOS 11.2 and above. See More

RealisticOmfale's Experience

Ios better than android See More

Top Pro

CarPlay

Available in select cars, CarPlay is built primarily around the use of Siri voice commands and prompts, providing an "eyes-free" experience where you can respond to incoming calls, dictate text messages, or access your music library from a vehicle. See More

Top Con

Unlike Android, it is proprietary

Top Pro

Support for standard sync protocols

Out of the box support for caldav and carddav. See More

Top Con

Apple is very unfriendly regarding warrenty and repair work.

If your devices breaks, they will just tell you to buy a new one. See More

Top Pro

Security

A trustworthy OS, secure for use with banking apps. See More

Top Con

Vendor lock-in

You are forced to use the Apple ecosystem. Like the AppStore or iTunes. See More

Top Pro

Apps request permissions when needed

Instead of an app asking for all permissions it will need when installed, iOS apps request permission to access certain parts of user's data only when the current action requires it. See More

Top Pro

Apple pay

Apple pay, an easy and secure payment option. See More

Top Pro

Longtime support for older smartphones / tablets

iPhones don't become obsolete in a year or so. Most of them get updates for even more than about 4 years. See More

See All

score 11 · Answer 4

Tizen

Top Con

Lack of apps

Top Pro

Open source

Specs

OS Family:Linux

Top Con

Aesthetically unappealing

Top Pro

Fast

Top Pro

HTML5-based

See All

score 3 · Answer 5

KaiOS

score 49 · Answer 6

Lineage OS

score 12 · Answer 7

Ubuntu Touch

score 10 · Answer 8

Firefox OS

score 28 · Answer 9

Windows 10 Mobile / Windows Phone

score 13 · Answer 10

BlackBerry

5 Options Considered

My Recommendation for Android

My Recommendation for Android

Customize what apps perform what actions

Fragmentation and security flaws due to negligence.

Open source

Wide variety of phones forces variance in quality

Lots of hardware choices

Difficult to use for pro audio

Integration with Google Services

App permission issues

Highly customizable

More integrated sharing options

Desktop and lockscreen widgets

Accessibility

Personal assistant with Google Now

Great user experience right out of the box

The most widely used mobile OS

Consistent back button makes navigation easy

Built-in screen recording

Cheap phones

Customizable multiple "desktops"

Security Updates

It's all yours. You can do anything you want with YOUR phone...

My Recommendation for Sailfish OS

My Recommendation for Sailfish OS

Unique gesture-based interface

Only a few native apps, needs Android support to access many apps

Lower power consumptions

Only a few available phones

No annoying search bar that you might not be able to remove

Inbuilt Terminal app and ssh essentials

Easy to use Swipe UI

No pre-installed Google services

Usability and privacy

Very customizable

Nearly monthly updates and security fixes

My Recommendation for iOS

My Recommendation for iOS

Great selection of high quality and polished apps

No file managing

Everything works very well out of the box

Not very customisable

Consistent performance

Inconveninet price and hardware lock-in

Easy to learn to use

Tied to Apple

Personal assistant called Siri

Older iPhone models with poorer batteries might perform slower

CarPlay

Unlike Android, it is proprietary

Support for standard sync protocols

Apple is very unfriendly regarding warrenty and repair work.

Security

Vendor lock-in

Apps request permissions when needed

Apple pay

Longtime support for older smartphones / tablets

My Recommendation for Tizen

My Recommendation for Tizen

Lack of apps

Open source

Aesthetically unappealing

Fast

HTML5-based

My Recommendation for KaiOS

My Recommendation for KaiOS

Don't see your favorite option? Add it.

My Recommendation for Lineage OS

My Recommendation for Lineage OS

My Recommendation for PrivatOS

My Recommendation for PrivatOS

My Recommendation for Ubuntu Touch

My Recommendation for Ubuntu Touch

My Recommendation for Firefox OS

My Recommendation for Firefox OS

My Recommendation for Windows 10 Mobile / Windows Phone

My Recommendation for Windows 10 Mobile / Windows Phone

My Recommendation for BlackBerry

My Recommendation for BlackBerry