Follow
Female FashionSkirtsWorkwear

What are the best pencil skirts for winter weather?

3
Options 
Considered
4
User 
Recs.
Last 
Updated
Related Questions
Activity
Ad
Have feedback or ideas?
Discord logoJoin our community
on Discord
Here’s the Deal
Slant is powered by a community that helps you make informed decisions. Tell us what you’re passionate about to get your personalized feed and help others.

3 Options Considered

3 Options ConsideredPriceLast Updated
J Crew No 2 Pencil Skirt
May 2, 2016
Ann Taylor Boiled Wool Skirt
May 2, 2016
Ann Taylor LOFT Wool Scuba Pencil Skirt
May 2, 2016
See Full List

J Crew No 2 Pencil Skirt

Add Video or Image
Anastasia Marchenkova
Top Pro

Classical and seasonal color options

•••
This is J. Crew's permanent collection line, meaning that while the classic colors (black, navy) are available all the time, every year there are new colors released in trendy colors.
Anastasia Marchenkova
Top Pro

Wool

•••
Wool will keep you warm in winter and in colder climates. The wool is thick and has a substantial weight. Can wear fleece lined tights underneath for additional warmth!
Anastasia Marchenkova
Top Con

Waist is large

•••
The waist tends to run large, especially for women with curvier hips, and may require tailoring. Buy the size that fits your largest measurement (hips or waist) and tailor down to fit perfectly.
See 1 more ProSee 1 more Pro

Ann Taylor Boiled Wool Skirt

Add Video or Image
Anastasia Marchenkova
Top Pro

Often discounted

•••
Ann Taylor often holds 40% off sales so this skirt can be bought at a good discount
Anastasia Marchenkova
Top Pro

Flared silhouette

•••
Allows you to wear tights underneath the skirt for additional warmth and won't look lumpy because the skirt is flared
Anastasia Marchenkova
Top Con

Not a true pencil skirt

•••
More of an a-line or flared silhouette
See 1 more ProSee 1 more Pro

Ann Taylor LOFT Wool Scuba Pencil Skirt

Add Video or Image
Anastasia Marchenkova
Top Pro

Scuba knit

•••
The scuba knit makes the fabric look expensive
Anastasia Marchenkova
Top Pro

Available in different lengths

•••
Available in regular, petite, and tall sizing to make sure the skirt hits at the knee
Anastasia Marchenkova
Top Con

Wool blend

•••
There is only 40% wool in this skirt, not full wool
See 1 more ProSee 1 more Pro

4 Community Recommendations

Callixtus
Ryan
Request recommendations from the community
No highlighted recommendations.
I Recommend...
Help millions of people make better decisions.
Each month, over 1.7 million people use Slant to find the best products and share their knowledge. Pick the tags you’re passionate about to get a personalized feed and begin contributing your knowledge.
undefined