When comparing MAMP vs Vagrant, the Slant community recommends MAMP for most people. In the question“What are the best Windows web development environment for PHP?” MAMP is ranked 4th while Vagrant is ranked 8th. The most important reason people chose MAMP is:
you can select php version easily
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro has phpselector
you can select php version easily
Pro Easy to use
MAMP usually takes mere seconds to install. It runs right out of the box, with no additional changes to your system required.
Pro Once correctly configured it is easy to expand the system and add new Projects
We chose this setup for our professional Drupal development workflow because it gives the most accurate representation of a deployment server, thus minimizing any development faults.
Pro Cross-platform portability
Allows to work with coding tools of your choice, on any underlying platform and create portable virtualized soft dev environments that will work equally well on any operating system, be it Windows, MacOS or Linux.
Cons
Con If you want to quickly get a PHP Environment going, this is not the best choice
You have to do some distinct editing of settings files in order to make it run the way you want.