When comparing Mastrad Macaron Baking Sheet vs Silpat, the Slant community recommends Silpat for most people. In the question“What are the best non-stick baking mats for macarons?” Silpat is ranked 1st while Mastrad Macaron Baking Sheet is ranked 2nd. The most important reason people chose Silpat is:
Roll it up and store it away, doesn't take up the space of a metal sheet.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Organized spacing
Helpful for beginners, so they know exactly where and how much to pipe.
Pro Easy to store
Roll it up and store it away, doesn't take up the space of a metal sheet.
Pro Retains moisture better
Silpats don't allow as much heat to be released.
Pro Keeps macarons round
Silpats don't change shape in heat.
Pro Even heat distribution
Pro Environmentally friendly
It's made of fiberglass mesh and food-grade silicone.
Pro Easy to clean
Just rinse with warm, soapy water, nothing sticks, so it'll just wash off.
Pro Truly non-stick
Nothing sticks. No need to spray oil or add butter (which would hurt the formation of macaron feet).
Cons
Con Needs greasing to be truly non-stick
Con Expensive
$25 for a half sheet size.
Con Can't be used alone
The sheet itself is flimsy and flexible, so it needs to be used in conjunction with a hard surface.