When comparing WeMo Insight vs Edimax SP-2101W, the Slant community recommends WeMo Insight for most people. In the question“What are the best smart switches?” WeMo Insight is ranked 1st while Edimax SP-2101W is ranked 9th. The most important reason people chose WeMo Insight is:
IFTTT (if this then that) allows you to set up conditional automations. So you can turn on or off devices attached to the switch based on conditions like time of day, your location or any trigger from 300+ services.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Very configurable thanks to IFTTT
IFTTT (if this then that) allows you to set up conditional automations. So you can turn on or off devices attached to the switch based on conditions like time of day, your location or any trigger from 300+ services.
Pro App has a simple button widget
Pro Integrates with Google Home
Pro Easy installation
The installation instructions are fairly basic - just connect to the switch's Wi-Fi, go into the WeMo app, make the connection, and then swap over to your regular Wi-Fi (if it works the first time).
Pro Get notified when the switch is activated
You can set up the Insight to send you app notifications when the switch is turned on or off based on set rules. So you can, for example, get notified only between 9am and 5pm while you are at work, and turn off notifications while you are at home.
Pro Good companion app
The WeMo app is simple to use, and provides quite a bit of information at a glance as well. There's a large power button to open/close the switch, as well as a timer which indicates how long the switch has been on for. It also shows data such as average on time each day, average cost and more.
Pro Can send reports about energy usage
You can get on demand reports of energy usage as well as set up Insight to email daily, weekly or monthly reports of energy usage.
Pro Scheduling allows switch to operate automatically
Scheduling can be done on either a weekly basis (same schedule for the whole week) or you can configure each day individually (e.g., the weekend can have a different schedule than the weekdays).
Pro Integrates with Alexa
Through Amazon's virtual assistant Alexa (found on the Amazon Echo ling of products) you can control the switch via voice.
Pro Third party hardware integration
WeMo is one of the leading Internet of Things ecosystems, and can integrate with a wide variety of other products that also support the WeMo standard.
Pro Support for rules
Rules determine when your lights are on and off (think of it like scheduling for events instead of times).
Pro Compatible across popular mobile ecosystems
With apps for both Android and iOS available, the vast majority of users in any house will be able to control this switch. This is an essential feature for households that have both Android and iOS users.
Pro Prevents unwanted setting adjustments
The app can require a password, which means that if the TV is plugged into one of these switches that your kids can't install the app and extend the auto-turn-off-time. This could also be a benefit if plugging in a basic home security system - plugging the security system into this switch isn't any less secure than plugging it straight into the wall.
Pro Easy visual energy cost tracking
This device senses the amount of power which is drawn from it while it is in use. You can configure the switch to turn off when a certain power limit has been reached (can be based on a daily, weekly, or monthly figure). Upon hitting this limit, it will notify you with an email.
You can also view past power requirements ranging from a day to a month to see when it draws the most power. this data can be displayed as the true power (measured in watts) or approximate cost.
Pro Scheduling allows appliances to work automatically
You can schedule the switch to turn off when you leave for work or go to bed, and to turn on when you get home from work or wake up. If you use a portable heater or air conditioner, this can be especially useful to pre-heat or cool your house just before you get home. This ensures your house is at the right temperature whenever you're home, but saves on power when you don't need it.
Pro Long term energy tracking
The power data will be kept for 12 months, allowing for long term comparison between multiple seasons.
Cons
Con Poor Android app
The in-app performance is poor - it lags and studders. Performing any actions takes a couple seconds to register, and the overall experience is bad. This could be due to the Wi-Fi connection, or it could just be a poorly optimized app.
Con Buggy setup
The setup process sounds simple enough - connect to the switch's Wi-Fi network to pair, and then swap back to your regular Wi-Fi. In practice, the connection is spontaneous. It takes a number of tries to set up the connection successfully.
Con Power button can be distracting
When the switch is on it illuminates the power button which can be distracting. Especially at night or when watching a movie. And there's no way to turn off the power button without turning off the switch.
Con Blocks other plugs
This switch is compact as far as smart switches go, however it is still large enough to block the other outlet on a typical 2 slot wall outlet.
Con Works only with devices that use more than 2 watts of power
Con No yet compatible with SmartThings hub
SmartThings is Samsung's smart home ecosystem. The WeMo Insight isn't compatible with Samsung's software.
Con No HomeKit support
Con No smart home intergration
This switch doesn't connect to any third party systems - no HomeKit, Nest, WeMo, Z-Wave, or other integration. These products work on their own without any external integration.
Con Lacks sunrise/sunset control
Many other switches can be configured to turn on at sunrise, and turn off at sunset (or vice versa if you have a light plugged into it). The Edimax SP-2101W lacks any such feature.
Con Somewhat bulky
This switch will block the plug beneath it, effectively reducing the number of plugs you have available in your house. This also makes it a more obvious eye-sore.
