When comparing DVDCreator vs DVD Styler, the Slant community recommends DVD Styler for most people. In the question“What is the best DVD authoring program for Macs?” DVD Styler is ranked 1st while DVDCreator is ranked 3rd. The most important reason people chose DVD Styler is:
Free for personal educational and commercial use, can install on as many machines as you want. See [here](www.gnu.org/copyleft/gpl.html).
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Free and GNU GPL
Free for personal educational and commercial use, can install on as many machines as you want. See here.
Pro Cross-platform
Available on Mac, Windows, Linux (Ubuntu) and available as source code if you want to build and compile it yourself.
Cons
Con Cannot save projects, work can easily be lost
Using the demo version, and their support confirmed it is true of the actual software, files cannot be saved. Compiling a DVD can be time consuming with any program, and if you close down, or it crashes, the file is lost. Bizarre. You can’t drag clips to any position on a list of contents, you can move up, down, one space or move to top or bottom of list is all. There is no way to have an overall title on the opening screen, see the picture. Authoring is a drag.
Con All options will not show when opened
Con No passthru / lossless options
DVD Styler will reencode all video and audio.
Con Bundleware
Con Can't make true HD DVDs ; Limited output / reencode options
DVD Styler offers presets for the following types:
CD - 700 MB
DVD 1 - 1.4 GB
DVD 2 - 2.6 GB
DVD 5 - 4.7 GB
DVD 9 - 8.5 GB
Unlimited
No presets are available for BlueRay or similar High Definition (HD) discs. There is no control over the size when using the Unlimited option. Other tools may necessary to compress contents to fit larger BlueRay DVDs.
Additionally, all video gets reencoded. Options for output is limited to two options:
Pal: 720 x 576 px
NTSC: 720 x 480 px
Thus it is not possible to create 1080 pixel or larger videos which is the minimum resolution to be considered true HD.
Aspect ratio is likewise limited to:
4:3
16:9
Audio gets reencoded as:
MP2 48 khz
AC3 48 khz
So this application is only fit for creating Standard Definition (SD) DVDs.