When comparing My First Stone Age vs Race to the Treasure, the Slant community recommends Race to the Treasure for most people. In the question“What are the best board games for kids?” Race to the Treasure is ranked 4th while My First Stone Age is ranked 5th. The most important reason people chose Race to the Treasure is:
Race to the Treasure introduces children to concepts such as making choices, prioritizing, and planning. Adults can guide kids to the best choices and explain them, which makes the game a good educational tool. There are many meaningful decisions to be made – where to place the tile, how to plan a route, picking between a key, an ogre snack, or the exit, etc.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Introduces many concepts
The complexity level of the game is great for younger children – it teaches them a lot more than just flipping tiles and moving, it also handles memory, resource management, and some risk.
The forest tiles are upside down, and two of them get flipped every time someone reaches the hut space, so you must keep track of where the tile you want is.
There’s quite a bit of trading and exchanging. When you land on the construction space, you trade in specific resources for a hut. The price of the hut is shown on the bottom of the hut tiles, it can either be three different resources or two resources of the same type. Also, when you reach the trading post tile, you can trade one resource for another.
The game also has a dog “wildcard”, which can substitute any resource, but there’s a catch – there are only two dogs in the game, and if they’re all taken when someone walks on the dog tile, then they can steal it from one of the players, so it’s a risk to hang on to it too long.
Pro Short play time
Kids and parents probably won’t get bored of the game so quickly because a full game takes only 15 to 20 minutes.
Pro Aesthetically pleasing
Similarly to the actual Stone Age, the artwork and the components look great, albeit with a cartoony twist, which befits a children’s game. The gameboard and hut tiles have cute prehistoric artwork that include little cavemen doing all kinds of silly stuff – swimming down waterfalls, playing, eating, etc. The 3D villages look very cool, and there’s no mistaking what the resource tokens are supposed to be.
Pro Durable components
My First Stone Age has high-quality components, so they should hold up very well. The meeples and the resource pieces are wooden, the cardboard huts and movement tokens are thick and rugged, the storage box is sturdy, and the cards are made of durable cardstock.
Pro Simple to learn
My First Stone Age is easy to play, as a children’s game should be. Players take turns flipping tokens that tell them where to move. The tokens feature either icons with specific spots or dice, in which case you must move the according amount of spaces. When you reach the hut space, then you can use combinations of resources you’ve gathered to build a hut. The first player to build three of them wins the game.
Pro Teaches a good variety of concepts
Race to the Treasure introduces children to concepts such as making choices, prioritizing, and planning. Adults can guide kids to the best choices and explain them, which makes the game a good educational tool. There are many meaningful decisions to be made – where to place the tile, how to plan a route, picking between a key, an ogre snack, or the exit, etc.
Pro Very easy
Race to the Treasure is extremely simple and can be taught in a matter of minutes to anyone. The mechanic is elementary – you draw a tile and place it. The tile can be either a path or an ogre. If it’s a path, then you decide where to connect it to the road you’re building. If it’s an ogre, then it’s added to the ogre track.
When you gather three keys and reach the exit, everyone wins. If the ogre reaches the exit first, you lose.
Pro Quick to play
Race to the Treasure can take a maximum of 20 minutes, which is short enough for keeping the attention of younger players and not taking too much time for adults.
Pro Fast to set up
Setting up the game is quick and easy. You place the board, shuffle the tiles, and then roll the two dice, one with a number and one with a letter, to determine where the keys and the ogre snacks are going to be placed on the 6x8 grid.
This also helps younger children with numbers and letters, so the setup can also be educational.
Cons
Con Might be outgrown quickly
The lifespan of My First Stone Age isn’t very long because the introduced concepts are quite basic and simple, so kids might find it repetitive, boring, and easy in a year or two.
Con Luck-based
The tile deck contains 10 ogre tiles, if 7 of them are placed, then the players lose. Depending on where these tiles might be after the deck is shuffled, your game can often end with a quick loss or an easy win.
Con Might require some house rules
There’s a gap in the rules for a situation where you draw a straight tile and the only space to place it goes off the board, which might require the introduction of a house rule to solve – re-drawing the tile, discarding it, adding an ogre tile, etc.
Alternative Products
