When comparing The Linux Gamer vs Luke Smith, the Slant community recommends Luke Smith for most people. In the question“What are the best Youtube channels for Linux content?” Luke Smith is ranked 1st while The Linux Gamer is ranked 26th. The most important reason people chose Luke Smith is:
He's not a programmer, or someone who particularly enjoys using computers, so he doesn't focus on the latest tools or computing fads. The channel is almost exclusively about what he finds helpful when doing his work.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Linux gaming advocate
Doesn't really care about multiplayer games though.
Pro One of the few Linux youtubers to feature gaming
He is one of the few Linux YouTubers to primarily feature gaming. Additionally, he uses the popular supporting gaming apps for his community such as Discord, Steam group, Twitch, and a Steam curated page of games.
Pro Approaches computing as a means to an end
He's not a programmer, or someone who particularly enjoys using computers, so he doesn't focus on the latest tools or computing fads. The channel is almost exclusively about what he finds helpful when doing his work.
Pro Amazing tutorials
It is possible to learn a lot from Luke.
Pro Concise, up to the point
No rambling and not too much proselytism.
Pro Great sense of humor
Pro Memes
Pro He is a good human
Not like some other YouTubers who beg for subscribers, he does his work genuinely.
Pro Efficient
He makes every task more efficient for himself and shares the tricks and tips. Always works in order to make his system less bloated. He won’t share everything, he will show you stuff and give you ideas but you may have to learn a lot from other sources to be able to implement it.
Pro Ubuntu hater
Cons
Con Many videos not saying much, dragged out for lack of better content
Con Gnome advocate
Not exactly a bad thing, but if you are expecting content diversification (not only related to the GTK/Gnome world), it can be a real pain.
Con Totally different on stream, gloomy when editing, doesn't like what he does
Makes him seem like a fake, smiley guy on video and a depressing guy elsewhere.
Con A lot of editing mistakes
Shows how little he reviews his videos before posting them.
Con Condescending, opinionated talk
Con Holds opinions that are contrary to Linux ethos
Opinions expressed in non Linux related videos are often extreme and discriminatory, in antitheses of the free and open source philosophy that surrounds Linux and software related to it.
Con Political
Con Decent Linux content is contaminated with toxic 4Chan memes
Hard to understand why a smart, introspective guy like Luke Smith undercuts his content by including all the 4Chan memes and obvious appeals to the most toxic elements of the audience. It seems to be like a bad habit for him, because he will make long form content and commentary on something interesting, then undermine it by putting 4chan thumbnails or catch phrases all over it.
Con Political
Con Ubuntu hater
